Supernatural Sanctuary Books in Order
Part ofKellie McAllen Books in OrderRead the Supernatural Sanctuary books by Kellie McAllen in order, with series background, book summaries, and guidance for this teen paranormal romance world.
Last updated: July 14, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Supernatural Sanctuary books in publication order
3 books
Dragon Scarred
by Kellie McAllen
2019
Scarlett has never stopped searching for the brother she saw become a dragon years ago. Finding an injured dragon and a hidden supernatural sanctuary gives her hope, but exposing its secrets could endanger everyone inside.
Fairy Charmed
by Kellie McAllen
2019
Elle has rejected fairy tales ever since her mother abandoned her over fears of changelings. Then Jinx appears with impossible claims about Elle's past, and she must face buried memories to protect the mysterious fairy drawing her close.
Wolf Claimed
by Kellie McAllen
2019
Luna ignores years of warnings and spends a night with forbidden Nikko, only to discover they are both werewolves. Claimed as his mate against her will, Luna is pulled into a pack war that threatens her freedom and family.
Supernatural Sanctuary books in chronological order
Series background & context
Supernatural Sanctuary is a teen paranormal romance series about young people who discover that myths are not myths at all. Werewolves, dragons, fairies, and other creatures exist, but they need places where they can live beyond the reach of a human world that would not understand them. The sanctuary becomes both a refuge and a source of new danger.
Each book spotlights a different couple while building the same shared world.
Wolf Claimed follows Luna, who has always been told to stay away from Nikko and his unsettling group of friends. One reckless night changes everything when Luna turns into a werewolf. Nikko knows her transformation makes her important to the pack, and Luna finds herself caught in a conflict where power, family, and her own freedom are all at stake.
In Dragon Scarred, Scarlett has spent years searching for her missing brother after seeing him turn into a dragon as a child. Nobody believed her, and the loss has shaped her entire life. When she encounters an injured dragon and finds the sanctuary, Scarlett discovers that legends are real, but so are the risks of revealing them. Helios, the dragon who helps her, becomes part of her search for the truth.
The sanctuary offers safety, but its secrets are fragile.
Fairy Charmed turns to Elle, who grew up in foster care after her mother became convinced that Elle was a fairy changeling. Elle has tried to protect herself by rejecting the supernatural stories that caused so much pain. Jinx arrives with claims about Elle's past and their connection, forcing her to question memories she thought were gone. The danger around him makes those answers urgent.
The books share a sense of discovery. The protagonists begin on the outside of the magical world, often doubting themselves or being doubted by others. Finding the sanctuary gives them community, but it does not erase old wounds or make the people around them automatically trustworthy. Romance develops alongside the larger problem of keeping the supernatural world safe.
Readers can enjoy the books as connected standalones, since each has a new central couple and creature focus. Still, beginning with Wolf Claimed gives the clearest introduction to the sanctuary and lets recurring characters build naturally. Expect contemporary paranormal romance with shifters, lost family, hidden histories, and young people learning that the strange thing they saw was real after all.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.



















Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts