Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

Kate Burkholder Books in Order

Part ofLinda Castillo Books in Order

Explore the Kate Burkholder Amish crime thrillers by Linda Castillo with books in order, quick summaries, series background, reading guide and suggested starting points.

Last updated: June 7, 2026

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Publication Order

Sort:

30 books

1

Sworn to Silence

by Linda Castillo

2009

2

Sworn to Silence

by Linda Castillo

2009

Sixteen years after a brutal killer terrorized Painters Mill, a new series of murders bears his signature. Former Amish police chief Kate Burkholder must confront the secret that stopped the original killings if she hopes to stop a copycat before he strikes again.

3

Pray for Silence

by Linda Castillo

2010

4

Pray for Silence

by Linda Castillo

2010

An entire Amish family is massacred on their secluded farm, leaving almost no clues and no obvious motive. As Kate Burkholder and state agent John Tomasetti investigate, a teenage girl’s hidden diary reveals a dangerous double life and a killer determined to stay in the shadows.

5

Breaking Silence

by Linda Castillo

2011

6

Breaking Silence

by Linda Castillo

2011

When three members of an Amish family are found dead in a manure pit, the tragedy first looks like a freak accident. As hate crimes against the Amish escalate, Kate Burkholder uncovers evidence of murder and a web of secrets tearing a close knit community apart.

7

Gone Missing

by Linda Castillo

2011

8

Gone Missing

by Linda Castillo

2011

Several Amish teens vanish during rumspringa, the season of freedom before joining the church, and one disappearance ends in murder. Called in for her Amish background, Kate Burkholder follows a chilling trail of runaway dreams, family lies and a predator who has been hunting for years.

9

Her Last Breath

by Linda Castillo

2013

10

Her Last Breath

by Linda Castillo

2013

A rainy night, a speeding car and a shattered buggy leave an Amish man and his children dead on a lonely road. When Kate Burkholder learns the victims are her childhood friend’s family, she digs into a hit and run that hides obsession, betrayal and long buried guilt.

11

The Dead Will Tell

by Linda Castillo

2014

12

The Dead Will Tell

by Linda Castillo

2014

A man is found hanging in a barn in what looks like suicide, but the details echo a decades old unsolved crime that wiped out an Amish family. As more deaths follow, Kate Burkholder must untangle the truth about that long ago night before the last witness dies.

13

After the Storm

by Linda Castillo

2015

14

After the Storm

by Linda Castillo

2015

When a tornado rips through Painters Mill, the storm uncovers human remains hidden in an Amish barn for thirty years. Juggling a brutal cold case, a lawsuit over a rescue gone wrong and a life changing secret of her own, Kate Burkholder uncovers a past no one wants exposed.

15

Among the Wicked

by Linda Castillo

2016

16

Among the Wicked

by Linda Castillo

2016

Rumors of abuse and the suspicious death of a teenage girl send Kate Burkholder undercover into a closed Amish community in rural New York. Posing as a widow, she must win the trust of fearful villagers, outthink a ruthless bishop and survive long enough to get the truth out.

17

Down a Dark Road

by Linda Castillo

2017

18

Down a Dark Road

by Linda Castillo

2017

When convicted wife killer Joseph King escapes from prison and returns to Painters Mill, Kate Burkholder is torn between childhood memories of her first crush and the damning evidence against him. After he takes desperate action to clear his name, Kate’s search for the truth turns deadly.

19

A Gathering of Secrets

by Linda Castillo

2018

20

A Gathering of Secrets

by Linda Castillo

2018

A young Amish man dies locked inside a burning barn, and the fire is quickly ruled an accident. As Kate Burkholder probes deeper, she discovers disturbing secrets about the victim and a community willing to protect its own, even if it means letting a killer walk free.

21

Shamed

by Linda Castillo

2019

22

Shamed

by Linda Castillo

2019

An Amish grandmother is brutally murdered and her seven year old granddaughter vanishes without a trace. Racing against time, Kate Burkholder uncovers a hidden adoption, tangled loyalties and a vengeful scheme that forces her to question what justice looks like in a world built on forgiveness.

23

Outsider

by Linda Castillo

2020

24

Outsider

by Linda Castillo

2020

During a blizzard an Amish widower finds an injured woman in a snow filled ditch, and Kate Burkholder is stunned to recognize her former friend, cop Gina Colorosa. As corrupt officers close in, Kate must decide how far she will go to protect Gina and expose a lethal cover up.

25

Fallen

by Linda Castillo

2021

26

Fallen

by Linda Castillo

2021

A young woman is beaten to death in a roadside motel, and Kate Burkholder is shocked to learn she once babysat the victim, a rebellious Amish girl who fled the faith. Digging into Rachael Schwartz’s double life, Kate uncovers blackmail, buried scandals and a killer with everything to lose.

27

The Hidden One

by Linda Castillo

2022

Human remains unearthed in rural Pennsylvania are identified as a revered Amish bishop who vanished eighteen years ago. When Kate Burkholder is asked to review the case, she questions the arrest of a former sweetheart and confronts powerful secrets the valley would rather leave buried.

28

An Evil Heart

by Linda Castillo

2023

A well liked young Amish man is found shot with a crossbow and left on a lonely road, his apparently spotless life hiding troubling contradictions. As Kate Burkholder digs deeper and a second body surfaces, she uncovers cruelty behind a pious facade while her own wedding day looms.

29

The Burning

by Linda Castillo

2024

Called to a midnight fire in the woods, newlywed Kate Burkholder discovers the charred body of an excommunicated Amish man chained to a stake. Her investigation into Milan Swanz’s brutal death exposes a buried chapter of Amish history and draws suspicion dangerously close to her own family.

30

Rage

by Linda Castillo

2025

When three Amish children stumble on dismembered remains in a field, Kate Burkholder is pulled into a savage double murder. The trail leads from quiet farms to the dark edges of online exploitation, forcing Kate to confront how rage and secrecy can twist even the most sheltered lives.

Series background & context

The Kate Burkholder books follow the life and work of Kate, a former Amish girl who returns to her hometown as chief of police. The series is set in Painters Mill, a small Ohio town surrounded by farms, cornfields and conservative church districts, where the Amish and the English live side by side.

When the series opens in Sworn to Silence, Kate has already left the Amish faith, survived a traumatic attack as a teenager and spent years in big city law enforcement. She comes back to Painters Mill carrying scars, secrets and a fierce sense of duty. Her background makes her an outsider to the Plain community, yet she speaks Pennsylvania Dutch, understands the Ordnung and can walk into homes and barns other cops would never see.

Each novel takes a different crime and asks how it would play out in a world shaped by non violence, forgiveness and a deep suspicion of outside authority. Kate investigates serial killings that echo an old horror from her youth, family massacres on isolated farms, missing teenagers on rumspringa and cold cases uncovered by tornadoes, fires or chance discoveries. Ordinary Amish settings, from schoolhouses to hay fields, become crime scenes when violence intrudes.

Alongside the cases, the books track Kate’s personal life. Her romance with state agent John Tomasetti grows from wary partnership into hard won trust, complicated by his own losses and their shared history with addiction and grief. Her small department in Painters Mill, a handful of officers with distinct strengths and tempers, becomes a kind of found family that backs her up when both Amish and English neighbors would rather she kept quiet.

One of the pleasures of the series is the way Castillo lets readers see both sides of the cultural divide. Kate is blunt about the flaws she sees in the community that raised her, especially when secrecy protects abusers or allows prejudice to fester. At the same time she understands the comfort of faith, the appeal of a slower life and the weight of turning your back on everything you once believed.

In addition to the full length novels, a run of novellas and short stories such as Long Lost, A Hidden Secret, Seeds of Deception and Only the Lucky fill in the gaps between books. Some glimpse Kate as a teen girl still living Amish. Others drop in on smaller cases in Painters Mill, showing quiet moments with John Tomasetti or the department while still delivering tight, suspenseful mysteries.

Across the series, readers can expect grounded police work, moody Midwestern weather and crimes that are less about sensational twists than about the painful choices people make when loyalty, faith and fear collide.

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

Comments

Did we miss something? Have feedback?

Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts

We only use your email to notify you about replies.

All comments are moderated.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.

All 30 Kate Burkholder Books in Order (Complete List 2026)