The Psalm 23 Mysteries Books in Order

Church secretary Cindy Preston finds a body in the sanctuary just before Easter, and the locked church raises more questions than answers. With Rabbi Jeremiah Silverman beside her, she starts hunting a killer who may strike again.

A Thanksgiving charity that pairs rescue dogs with homeless people turns grim when the recipients begin dying and the dogs vanish. Cindy and Jeremiah have to find out who is profiting from the murders.

Around St. Patrick's Day, Cindy and Jeremiah face an unscrupulous land developer and a murder that disrupts an idyllic landscape. To stop more harm, they have to untangle greed, power, and a threat aimed at vulnerable teens.

A Memorial Day trip to Hawaii sounds like a break for Cindy, but trouble follows her there too. Paradise quickly gives way to another murder and another puzzle she cannot ignore.

A wedding should be joyful, but this one comes wrapped in danger and suspicion. Cindy and Jeremiah have to untangle the threat before celebration turns into tragedy.

Cindy and Jeremiah have already survived more than most amateur sleuths ever would, but peace never lasts long around them. Another holiday-season mystery tests both their instincts and their growing trust.

An old mystery lies at the center of a new crime, drawing Cindy and Jeremiah into a case with deeper roots than they expected. The farther they dig, the more personal the danger feels.

Halloween should bring costumes and harmless scares, but Cindy finds herself in the middle of another very real threat. As the holiday grows darker, she and Jeremiah have to sort out who is playing games and who means to kill.

Just when Cindy thinks she finally understands the danger around Jeremiah, darker truths emerge. Another case forces them to face secrets that could change everything between them.

A murder at a political rally hosted by the church forces Cindy and Jeremiah into another complicated case. At the same time, Cindy is pulled toward family trouble and a stalker who wants to know far too much about her.

Months of strain have left Cindy and Jeremiah on shaky ground, and another investigation does not make things easier. As danger rises, they have to decide whether their bond can survive the pressure.

Cindy's jury duty on a high-profile trial should have been an inconvenience, not a threat. But once violence and suspicion enter the courtroom, she is stuck in the middle of a case that feels anything but ordinary.

Cindy is already dreading Mother's Day when family tensions and fresh danger collide. What should have been a difficult visit turns into another case with personal stakes.

A sudden tragedy shatters the fragile peace around Cindy and Jeremiah, and grief quickly gives way to danger. As emotions run high, they have to sort out what happened before the next blow falls.

Jeremiah has worked hard to leave his past behind, but old enemies refuse to let him go. As danger closes in, Cindy and the people around him are forced to face just how costly that past may be.

When an arsonist begins targeting synagogues, Jeremiah and Cindy are pulled into a case fueled by fear and hatred. To stop more violence, they have to uncover who is behind the attacks before the damage spreads.

Cindy, Jeremiah, Mark, Traci, Joseph, and Geanie head to New Orleans to help a friend and walk straight into a deadly game. Trapped with an enemy who seems to know everything about them, they also have to wonder if one of their own can be trusted.

When Mark Walters finds a dead body in his backyard, he, Cindy, and Jeremiah are pulled into a case tied to girls working at The Zone theme park. As New Year's Eve closes in, a second threat raises the stakes even higher.

Green Pastures camp reopens, and a staff retreat sends Cindy, Jeremiah, and their friends back to a place full of bad memories. A hunt for rumored cult treasure turns the trip into a fight for survival.

Friends plan separate bachelor and bachelorette parties for Jeremiah and Cindy, but both trips go wildly wrong. An isolated mansion, a reckless Vegas weekend, and danger on every side leave the whole group struggling to get home alive.