The Donnelly Cabin Inn Books in Order
Part ofJoanne Pence Books in OrderSee The Donnelly Cabin Inn books in order by Joanne Pence, with short summaries, series background, and where to start this warm, ghost-touched romance series.
Last updated: July 9, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
The Donnelly Cabin Inn books in publication order
5 books
If I Loved You
by Joanne Pence
2021
Carly Fullerton and thriller writer Alex Townson both arrive expecting solitude at the same remote cabin. Forced to share the place, they soon realize the resident ghosts may have plans of their own.
Sentimental Journey
by Joanne Pence
2021
A woman who insists she is not looking for love needs the cabin's income badly enough to rent it out. Then a French wildlife biologist arrives, and the quiet arrangement turns into something far more complicated.
This Can't be Love
by Joanne Pence
2021
Another stay at the Donnelly cabin throws two wary strangers together when both would rather be alone. As odd happenings mount, they have to decide whether the place is haunted, or simply very determined to change their lives.
A Certain Smile
by Joanne Pence
2023
Heartbroken fashion photographer Sophie Evans and troubled former rancher Tray Bowman arrive separately at the Donnelly Cabin Inn. The ghosts there seem convinced the two damaged strangers belong together, whether they agree or not.
Time After Time
by Joanne Pence
2023
A preserved wedding dress and a packet of old letters send Charlotte Truscott searching into her family's past. At the Donnelly Cabin Inn, and with help from Deputy Sheriff Joseph Murrieta, she begins to imagine a different future.
The Donnelly Cabin Inn books in chronological order

If I Loved You
by Joanne Pence
2021The Donnelly Cabin Inn, Book 1
This Can't be Love
by Joanne Pence
2021The Donnelly Cabin Inn, Book 2
Sentimental Journey
by Joanne Pence
2021The Donnelly Cabin Inn, Book 3
A Certain Smile
by Joanne Pence
2023The Donnelly Cabin Inn, Book 4
Time After Time
by Joanne Pence
2023The Donnelly Cabin Inn, Book 5
Series background & context
The Donnelly Cabin Inn books are warm, romantic, and gently haunted. At the center of the series is a remote mountain property that begins as a secluded cabin and gradually becomes an inn, but the building is more than a quiet getaway. It has a history, a personality, and a habit of nudging the right people into the same place at exactly the right time.
The ghosts help.
That does not mean the series turns into horror. The paranormal element is light, affectionate, and often a little playful. Strange things happen. Objects seem to move. Old presences linger. Guests start to suspect that the cabin, and later the inn, may be trying to match lonely, stubborn, or wounded people who would never have chosen each other on their own. The supernatural side gives the books a distinct feel, but the real focus is always the emotional journey.
Each story brings in a new couple, usually people carrying disappointment, grief, exhaustion, regret, or a life that has gone off course. One person may arrive looking for rest. Another may be hiding from some kind of failure. Sometimes both want solitude and get each other instead. The cabin has a way of making those collisions feel believable. The setting is isolated enough that characters cannot easily run from themselves, which is part of the point.
That atmosphere matters a lot. These books are full of mountain quiet, old rooms, repaired histories, and the sense that a place can hold memory. By the later books, when the property becomes the Donnelly Cabin Inn, the world opens up a little more, but the mood stays much the same. People come there bruised by life and leave changed, whether or not they ever fully admit the ghosts had a hand in it.
The tone is hopeful, not sugary.
There is romance, of course, but there is also healing, second chances, family history, and the practical work of letting another person into your life. Some books add light mystery elements or old secrets that need to be uncovered, but the emotional stakes stay front and center. Readers who like closed, intimate settings and relationships that build under pressure will feel at home here.
If you want paranormal romance without heavy lore, and if you like the idea of a haunted place acting as an invisible matchmaker, this series is an easy one to sink into. If I Loved You is the clear place to begin.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.















Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts