Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

Library Lover's Mystery Books in Order

Part ofJenn McKinlay Books in Order

Explore the Library Lover's Mystery books in order by Jenn McKinlay, with short summaries, Briar Creek background, and easy starting points.

Last updated: June 8, 2026

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Publication Order

Sort:

16 books

1

Books Can Be Deceiving

by Jenn McKinlay

2011

Library director Lindsey Norris is just settling into Briar Creek when a visiting editor stirs up local ambition. Then a famous author is murdered and Lindsey's friend Beth becomes the prime suspect.

2

Book, Line and Sinker

by Jenn McKinlay

2012

Treasure hunters arrive in Briar Creek to search Pirate Island, and the town quickly splits over the attention. When a local woman is murdered at the dig site, Lindsey has to clear a friend before the truth is buried for good.

3

Due or Die

by Jenn McKinlay

2012

A nor'easter traps Briar Creek under snow just as Carrie Rushton is accused of killing her husband. With the police stretched thin, Lindsey Norris and the crafternoon club start digging for the truth.

4

Read It and Weep

by Jenn McKinlay

2013

Lindsey Norris wants no part of community theater chaos, but Briar Creek's production of A Midsummer Night's Dream pulls her in anyway. When one of the cast is poisoned, she has to solve the case before opening night closes for good.

5

On Borrowed Time

by Jenn McKinlay

2014

Lindsey's world-traveling brother Jack vanishes, and a coffee clue is one of the few trails he leaves behind. As she follows the case into stranger territory, Lindsey risks much more than her holiday plans.

6

A Likely Story

by Jenn McKinlay

2015

On a routine book run to a remote island, Lindsey and Sully find one reclusive brother shot dead and the other missing. To untangle what happened, Lindsey has to work through years of secrets and suspicion.

7

Better Late Than Never

by Jenn McKinlay

2016

An overdue book amnesty day seems harmless until Lindsey notices one copy of The Catcher in the Rye was checked out by a teacher murdered twenty years earlier. The returned book may be the clue that finally breaks the cold case.

8

Death in the Stacks

by Jenn McKinlay

2017

Briar Creek Library's big annual fund-raiser should be Lindsey's easiest night of the year. But when the difficult board president ends up dead and a new employee is found beside the body, Lindsey has another case on her hands.

9

Hitting the Books

by Jenn McKinlay

2018

A hit and run appears to be linked to borrowed library materials, pulling Lindsey into another Briar Creek investigation. When the victim is attacked again and the stolen car's driver turns up dead, the case gets far more dangerous.

10

Word to the Wise

by Jenn McKinlay

2019

Lindsey should be focused on wedding plans, but a pushy newcomer named Aaron Grady will not leave her alone. When he is found dead outside the library and the evidence points to Sully, Lindsey goes all in on the case.

11

One for the Books

by Jenn McKinlay

2020

Lindsey and Sully are finally getting married, until a trip to scout a wedding site leads to a body washed up on Bell Island. The dead man was meant to officiate the ceremony, which makes the mystery feel uncomfortably personal.

12

Killer Research

by Jenn McKinlay

2021

Spring in Briar Creek looks peaceful until librarian Ms. Cole opens her trunk and finds a dead man from her past inside. Lindsey, Sully, and the crafternoon crew have to solve the case before the mayoral race is destroyed.

13

The Plot and the Pendulum

by Jenn McKinlay

2022

A donation pickup at an old Victorian estate reveals a secret room, a skeleton, and a copy of Poe. Lindsey quickly connects the remains to a decades-old Briar Creek disappearance and starts reopening a very cold case.

14

A Merry Little Murder Plot

by Jenn McKinlay

2024

Briar Creek's holiday season grows tense when famous writer Helen Monroe arrives as writer in residence with a bad attitude and a secretive fan nearby. When the fan turns up dead, Lindsey has to defend the very last person anyone expected.

15

Fatal First Edition

by Jenn McKinlay

2024

A rare inscribed Patricia Highsmith first edition falls into Lindsey's hands at a Chicago library conference, then the conference director is murdered on the train ride home. Soon Lindsey and Sully are carrying the evidence and the suspicion.

16
New

Booking for Trouble

by Jenn McKinlay

2026

Lindsey launches a new book-boat service to bring library books to the small islands off Briar Creek. Then she and Sully find a body on the rocks and get caught in a family feud full of buried secrets.

Series background & context

The Library Lover's Mystery books are set in Briar Creek, a coastal Connecticut town where the public library sits right at the center of community life. The main character, Lindsey Norris, is the library director, which makes her equal parts organizer, researcher, town listener, and accidental sleuth.

The library really is the heart of the series.

Lindsey is surrounded by people who make Briar Creek feel lived in, not just quaint. There is her staff, the regulars, the crafternoon group, and the friends who keep showing up when trouble starts. Her relationship with boat captain Mike Sullivan, usually called Sully, becomes one of the long-running threads, so the books reward reading in order. As the series goes on, you get not just fresh murders but a fuller sense of Lindsey's town, work, and personal life.

The cases themselves are wonderfully bookish without getting too cute about it. McKinlay ties crimes to authors, overdue books, literary events, library fund-raisers, local history, island trips, cold cases, and even train travel. The first book, Books Can Be Deceiving, introduces the basic appeal right away: a smart librarian, a close community, and a murder that pulls the library world into the investigation. Later titles widen the scope while keeping the same cozy core.

The coastal setting matters, too. Ferries, storms, rocky shorelines, nearby islands, and old houses give Briar Creek a distinct feel. This is not a generic small town. It is a place where people gossip, volunteer, run for office, write books, hold craft events, and still make time to argue over who has checked out what.

If you like traditional cozy mysteries with a warm setting, recurring characters, and plenty of reading and research folded into the plot, this series is easy to sink into. Start with Books Can Be Deceiving and go in order. Lindsey's world grows book by book, and that slow build is a big part of why readers get attached to Briar Creek.

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

Comments

Did we miss something? Have feedback?

Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts

We only use your email to notify you about replies.

All comments are moderated.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.

All 16 Library Lover's Mystery Books in Order (2026)