Amish Romance Books in Order

Isaac thinks his shy older brother Simon would be perfect for the pretty Amish schoolteacher, but Simon is too tongue tied to act. Determined to give his brother the best Christmas present ever, Isaac hatches a series of schemes that tangle school programs, family gatherings, and unexpected feelings.

When her husband dies in a barn raising accident, Ruth Miller is left to raise six children alone in their Amish community. As Christmas nears and bills pile up, unexpected help arrives in the form of neighbors, a persistent bachelor, and a mysterious visitor who may change everything.

Mary faces a Christmas full of painful farewells as circumstances force her to leave the Amish community and people she loves. Packing memories along with her few belongings, she must trust that God can meet her in a new place even when her heart still clings to the old.

Strong willed Becky is sure she knows exactly what kind of husband she wants and is quick to dismiss quiet, serious men. When circumstances push her into working closely with someone she once overlooked, she has to admit that God’s idea of a perfect match may surprise her.

Lonely and often overlooked, Henry has longed for both a family and a dog of his own. One winter, an unexpected chain of events brings him a loyal canine companion and opens the door to a hard earned love that might finally give him the home he has dreamed of.

Young Elsie longs for a horse of her own more than anything, but her Amish family has little money and many worries. When an unexpected opportunity finally brings a horse into her life, Elsie must learn responsibility, patience, and how love can arrive in very ordinary ways.

Teenage John, the youngest of seven Amish brothers, is sidelined by mysterious exhaustion and pain that turns out to be Lyme disease. As his illness stretches on, family tensions flare and jealousy over his brother’s courtship grows, even while John slowly discovers inner strength and a surprising chance at love.

Edna Miller has spent years loving shy Emery from afar, turning down other suitors while she waits. When he finally notices her and she also grows close to Orva, a widower she works for, Edna must trust God as she chooses between long held dreams and unexpected affection.

After her husband dies and a fire destroys their barn, Amish widow Annie faces winter with eight children and mounting bills. A friendship with a widower who has six children of his own brings laughter, chaos, and the possibility that two hurting families might become one.

Best friends since childhood, David Stolzfus and Anna Fisher grow into first love on neighboring Lancaster County farms. When David’s hunger for freedom sends him overseas and another young man writes to Anna, both must untangle loyalty, desire, and faith before they can see what their future should be.

As Christmas approaches, Liz helps with a holiday program while quietly remembering the heartbreak of a broken engagement. Working at the market and spending time with a steady widower, she slowly learns that saying yes to new joy does not erase old sorrow but can soften its edges.

Emma leaves her Amish community to nanny for an English family on the North Carolina coast, where ocean breezes and a charming Amish contractor upend her careful plans. When distance, silence, and a new friendship with a former Amish man complicate everything, she must decide what kind of life she truly wants.

Years after her fiancé called off their wedding weeks before the big day, Liz has settled into life as a single woman working at an Amish market restaurant. When her kind but reserved boss begins to notice her in new ways at Christmastime, she has to risk her heart again.