Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

13 Best Susan Elizabeth Phillips Books

The best Susan Elizabeth Phillips books, ranked by how many expert sources recommend each one, with notes on who each suits and where to begin reading.

Our take

Susan Elizabeth Phillips writes romances full of sparring, stubborn people, and communities that refuse to stay in the background. Her characters often arrive with damaged reputations, financial trouble, or a carefully defended heart. The jokes can be broad, but the emotional stakes include grief, shame, family estrangement, and the work of rebuilding a life.

The Chicago Stars books connect football players, team staff, and their families, with a different central couple in each story. It Had to Be You begins that world, while Match Me If You Can offers matchmaking comedy and Dream a Little Dream takes a more painful route through loss. Outside the series, Kiss an Angel uses a circus setting, and Ain’t She Sweet? centres on a former bully’s return home. Several older books rely on coercive or deceptive premises, so the kind of conflict you enjoy matters as much as the setting. Start with Match Me If You Can for banter, or Dream a Little Dream for a more emotional read.

13 books · 6 sources · Last updated

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Reading Susan Elizabeth Phillips in order? See all Susan Elizabeth Phillips books in order

How to choose from this list

Skip to the full ranking

If you want to begin Chicago Stars: It Had to Be You → Heaven, Texas
If you want comedy and banter: Match Me If You Can → Natural Born Charmer
If you want grief and second chances: Dream a Little Dream → Ain't She Sweet?
If you want a different setting: Breathing Room → Heroes Are My Weakness

The 13 books, ranked

Ranked by how many expert sources name each book. Ties go to the book more people recommend.

1

Natural Born Charmer

Chicago Stars, Book 7

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips2007

For readers who want comic sparring alongside a messy extended family. Its artist heroine and football-star hero offer a lively contrast, though the many supporting characters can pull attention away from the central couple.

What it's about

On a lonely Colorado highway, Chicago Stars quarterback Dean Robillard brakes for a furious woman in a bedraggled beaver costume. Taking runaway artist Blue Bailey along on his road trip leads them to a Tennessee farmhouse, an eccentric makeshift family, and a romance neither commitment phobe saw coming.

2

Dream a Little Dream

Chicago Stars, Book 4

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips1998

For readers who want a more emotional romance about rebuilding after loss. The child and wider family give the relationship added weight, though poverty, grief, and early hostility make it less breezy than the sports comedies.

What it's about

Down to her last dollars, widowed Rachel Stone limps back to Salvation, North Carolina, the town that despises her late televangelist husband. A job at grim widower Gabe Bonner's failing drive in gives her and her young son a precarious foothold and offers Gabe a second chance at faith and love.

3

Ain't She Sweet?

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips2004

For readers who enjoy a difficult heroine earning a second chance. Its interest in accountability gives the town’s grudges emotional force, though the bullying history and revenge make this a pricklier choice than a light comedy.

What it's about

Once the spoiled princess of Parrish, Mississippi, Sugar Beth Carey comes home broke and humbled to the town she tormented. Her former teacher Colin Byrne, now a famous novelist and owner of her old house, wants revenge, but proximity forces them to confront old wounds and the possibility of forgiveness.

4

It Had to Be You

Chicago Stars, Book 1

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips1994

For readers who want to begin the Chicago Stars series with sharp workplace conflict. Phoebe’s struggle to be taken seriously gives the romance purpose, though some sexual attitudes and references reflect its 1990s origins.

What it's about

After her domineering father dies, flamboyant heiress Phoebe Somerville unexpectedly inherits the Chicago Stars football team with one brutal condition: win or lose it. To survive the season she must battle stubborn head coach Dan Calebow, the game she hates, and the risk of trusting love again.

5

Kiss an Angel

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips1996

For readers who want a standalone with an unusual setting and substantial emotional strain. The circus and animal relationships distinguish it from the football romances, though the coerced marriage and harsh hero are significant tradeoffs.

What it's about

Flighty socialite Daisy Devreaux can either go to jail or enter an arranged marriage with grim circus manager Alex Markov. Dragged into a rough traveling show, she learns to care for neglected animals, confronts long buried family secrets, and falls for a man who believes he cannot love.

6

Match Me If You Can

Chicago Stars, Book 6

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips2005

For readers who want matchmaking comedy and a heroine building her own business. The client relationship creates sustained banter, though the book’s older treatment of gender and relationships may stand out to present-day readers.

What it's about

Determined to save her late grandmother's struggling matchmaking agency, quirky Annabelle Granger vows to land high powered sports agent Heath Champion as a client. As she parades Chicago's most polished women in front of him, their sparring turns playful and Annabelle begins to look like his most unlikely perfect match.

7

Nobody's Baby But Mine

Chicago Stars, Book 3

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips1997

For readers who enjoy clever opposites and an outrageous premise that develops into family conflict. Its comedy has a sharper edge than a gentle romance, and the reproductive deception may make the relationship difficult to accept.

What it's about

Brilliant physicist Jane Darlington wants a baby but fears passing on her isolating genius, so she targets seemingly dim Chicago Stars quarterback Cal Bonner as the perfect father. Her outrageous deception sparks a shotgun marriage, a custody battle, and a tender love between two stubborn opposites.

8

This Heart of Mine

Chicago Stars, Book 5

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips2001

For readers invested in the Chicago Stars family who want a more troubled romantic arc. Molly’s creative life and vulnerability add depth, though the relationship begins with sexual assault and also involves pregnancy loss.

What it's about

Children's book creator Molly Somerville has always secretly adored Chicago Stars quarterback Kevin Tucker, her sister's star player. One reckless night upends both their lives and sends them to a remote lakeside camp, where a fragile marriage of convenience slowly turns into the partnership they never planned.

9

Call Me Irresistible

Wynette, Texas, Book 6

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips2010

For readers who enjoy a town turning against an outsider and a seemingly perfect hero being challenged. Its delayed access to his viewpoint adds uncertainty, though the community’s hostility can feel relentless.

What it's about

Free spirited Meg Koranda arrives in Wynette, Texas to stand up in her best friend's wedding to golden boy Ted Beaudine, then realizes the match is all wrong. When the bride bolts, the furious town makes Meg their scapegoat, trapping her in dead end jobs and a slow burn battle of wills with the man she tried to save.

10

Heaven, Texas

Chicago Stars, Book 2

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips1995

For readers who enjoy an overlooked heroine challenging a celebrity’s self-image. Gracie’s practical competence makes the imbalance between them engaging, though Bobby Tom’s treatment of her and the makeover premise can feel dated.

What it's about

Buttoned up organizer Gracie Snow has one job: deliver legendary ex wide receiver Bobby Tom Denton home to Heaven, Texas for his first movie role. Instead she ends up remaking his chaotic life, challenging his playboy image, and discovering that a small town can change them both.

11

Breathing Room

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips2002

For readers who want reinvention and romance away from the football world. The Tuscan setting and self-help heroine offer a change of pace, though the spiritual themes and village intrigue may not suit everyone.

What it's about

America's favorite self help guru Dr. Isabel Favor loses her money, fiancé, and reputation in one spectacular crash, then retreats to a crumbling farmhouse in the Tuscan hills. There she collides with movie villain Ren Gage, a jaded star hiding from his own life, and together they relearn how to trust and start over.

12

First Star I See Tonight

Chicago Stars, Book 8

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips2016

For readers who like their romantic banter paired with an investigation. Piper’s work gives the leads a practical reason to clash, though the mystery and nightclub troubles share space with the developing relationship.

What it's about

Rookie private investigator Piper Dove's first big assignment is to shadow retired Chicago Stars legend Cooper Graham and see if he is hiding anything from a potential investor. When Coop catches her, he hires his not so stealthy stalker to uncover sabotage at his nightclub, turning their wary partnership into something much more dangerous to their hearts.

13

Heroes Are My Weakness

by Susan Elizabeth Phillips2014

For readers who enjoy gothic atmosphere mixed with romantic comedy. The isolated island and uncertain past add suspense, though the puppets and tonal shifts make it a less conventional introduction to the author.

What it's about

Flat broke actress and puppeteer Annie Hewitt trudges through a Maine snowstorm to the bleak cottage she has inherited, only to find brooding novelist Theo Harp in the looming mansion up the hill. Years after she believed he tried to kill her, mysterious threats and an unwanted attraction make it hard to know whom to trust.

Sources

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shape MRB and its growth.

Comments

Spotted a missing book, a wrong order or a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix this page.

We're a reading guide, not the author or publisher, so we can't send books or pass on messages.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.