Proper Romance Victorian / Dread Penny Society Books in Order
Part ofSarah M Eden Books in OrderBrowse the Proper Romance Victorian and Dread Penny Society books by Sarah M Eden in order, with series reading guide, story overviews, and notes on how the penny dreadfuls connect.
Last updated: December 23, 2025
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Publication Order
6 books
The Queen and the Knave
by Sarah M Eden
2023
The final Dread Penny Society novel brings together spy Móirín Donnelly and investigator Fitz Parkington as they work to unmask a criminal mastermind. Old allies, penny dreadful plots, and London’s underworld converge in a race that could cost them both their lives and their chance at love.
The Bachelor and the Bride
by Sarah M Eden
2022
In this Dread Penny Society installment, a solitary investigator and a resourceful young woman enter a pragmatic marriage only to find their partnership tested by hidden identities, ruthless enemies, and the dangerous mission that first brought them together.
The Merchant and the Rogue
by Sarah M Eden
2021
Irish immigrant Brogan Donnelly goes undercover at a suspicious London print shop for the Dread Penny Society and meets Vera Sorokina, a principled bookseller. Together they unravel a scheme preying on the poor, even as their unlikely friendship deepens into romance.
The Gentleman and the Thief
by Sarah M Eden
2020
Financially ruined gentleman Hollis Darby secretly writes penny dreadfuls and aids the Dread Penny Society. When he crosses paths with music teacher Ana Newport, who moonlights as a thief to protect her family, their undercover lives collide amid a dangerous conspiracy in Victorian London.
The Lady and the Highwayman
by Sarah M Eden
2019
In Victorian London, prim school headmistress Elizabeth Black secretly writes sensational penny dreadfuls under a male pseudonym. When streetwise author Fletcher Walker seeks her help unmasking his mysterious rival, their work with the Dread Penny Society tangles them in danger and unexpected romance.
Ashes on the Moor
by Sarah M Eden
2018
Banished to a bleak Yorkshire mill town after family tragedy, gentle teacher Evangeline Blake is tasked with educating rough local children. With the help of Irish brickmaker Dermot and his young brother, she slowly builds a new community and risks her guarded heart.
Series background & context
The Proper Romance Victorian books, especially the Dread Penny Society arc, dive into gaslit London, where popular penny dreadfuls and secret societies intersect with matters of the heart. The series balances adventure and mystery with closed door romance, all framed by the world of cheap serialized fiction that fascinated nineteenth century readers.
In The Lady and the Highwayman, school headmistress Elizabeth Black lives a double life. By day she runs a respectable school for girls and writes refined silver fork novels. By night she secretly pens gothic penny dreadfuls under the name Mr. King. Fletcher Walker, a former street urchin turned bestselling penny dreadful author, is part of the Dread Penny Society, a covert group of writers who use their earnings and street connections to protect vulnerable children. When Mr. King’s success threatens the society’s efforts, Fletcher turns to Elizabeth, not realizing she is the rival writer he seeks.
Subsequent novels focus on new couples while gradually advancing an overarching conflict. The Gentleman and the Thief pairs Hollis Darby, a gentleman whose fortune is dwindling, with Ana Newport, a music teacher who moonlights as a thief to keep her family afloat. The Merchant and the Rogue follows Irish immigrant Brogan Donnelly as he infiltrates a suspicious print shop and meets Vera Sorokina, a principled bookseller trying to shield her neighborhood from exploitation.
The Bachelor and the Bride and The Queen and the Knave raise the stakes further, drawing in investigators, masterminds, and long running enemies of the Dread Penny Society. Throughout, chapters of in universe penny dreadfuls are interspersed with the main narrative, echoing and reframing the dangers the characters face in their real lives.
What ties the series together is a focus on ordinary Londoners caught in extraordinary circumstances. Street children, shopkeepers, and overworked teachers stand alongside lords and ladies. The Dread Penny Society itself embodies the idea that storytelling can be an act of resistance and compassion.
Readers can pick up any of the Victorian titles on its own, but reading the Dread Penny books in publication order gives the clearest view of the secret society’s evolution and of the found family that grows up around it.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.
Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts