PI Matthew Hill Books in Order
Part ofTeresa Driscoll Books in OrderSee the PI Matthew Hill series by Teresa Driscoll in order, with brief summaries, character background, and a quick guide to the best place to start.
Last updated: June 8, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Publication Order
4 books
I Will Make You Pay
by Teresa Driscoll
2019
Every Wednesday, journalist Alice Henderson gets another chilling threat, and soon it is clear the caller wants her punished. With danger spreading to her family, she and Matthew Hill must uncover what from her past has come for her.
The Promise
by Teresa Driscoll
2019
Three school friends swore to bury a terrible secret, but decades later the past starts pushing back. Beth turns to PI Matthew Hill as old guilt, broken friendships, and danger to her family close in.
Her Perfect Family
by Teresa Driscoll
2021
Rachel Hartley's daughter Gemma is shot at her graduation, and what should have been a proud family day turns into a nightmare. As PI Matthew Hill investigates, buried lies inside the family make the case more dangerous.
Close Your Eyes
by Teresa Driscoll
2025
PI Matthew Hill is used to hunting for missing children, but this time the missing child is his own daughter, Amelie. As the search tightens, an old threat from his police past feels terrifyingly real.
Series background & context
The PI Matthew Hill books sit where private investigator fiction meets domestic suspense. Matthew is the recurring thread, but Teresa Driscoll is just as interested in the families, witnesses, and frightened ordinary people around a case as she is in the case itself. These stories usually begin with one bad shock, an old promise returning, a stalker closing in, a daughter shot at her graduation, or a child vanishing, and then follow the damage as it spreads through a household or community.
Matthew is not a swaggering detective.
He is a former police officer who now works as a private investigator, and that position shapes the whole series. He understands procedure and still knows how official investigations move, but he also stands just outside them. That lets him spend time with the people who are hurting, listen closely, and notice what others miss. He is often less interested in a dramatic confession than in the small pause, the half-truth, or the detail someone keeps skirting around.
That gives the books a slightly different feel from a straight procedural. In The Promise, I Will Make You Pay, and Her Perfect Family, the mystery is tied to guilt, secrecy, and long memory as much as to evidence. Matthew often arrives after the first crack has already appeared, when someone is being watched, threatened, or forced back toward a buried truth. He becomes the bridge between private fear and public investigation.
Place matters too. These novels unfold in recognisable modern settings, homes, schools, villages, workplaces, public journeys, and tight local communities where people think they know one another. Because the backdrop is so ordinary, the danger feels close. Driscoll's main interest is the ripple effect of crime, so the stakes are not just about solving a puzzle. They are about trust, reputation, old loyalties, and whether a family can survive what is about to come out.
The personal thread grows stronger as the books go on. Matthew has a wife, Sally, and later their daughter, Amelie, so he is never just an observer passing through somebody else's disaster. By the time Close Your Eyes turns the nightmare directly onto his own family, the emotional hit lands harder because earlier books have already shown the weight he carries from the past and the empathy he brings to missing-person cases.
These novels work best as linked standalones. Each has its own central crisis, so you can start almost anywhere, but reading in order lets Matthew's history build quietly in the background. Expect quick-moving suspense, plenty of emotional pressure, and stories where fear, shame, and love are often tangled together.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.


















Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts