Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries Books in Order

Part ofMara Webb Books in Order

Find the Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries by Mara Webb in order, with quick summaries, series background, and a simple guide to where to start.

Last updated: July 8, 2026

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries books in publication order

Sort:

15 books

1

All Wands on Deck

by Mara Webb

2021

Sadie Alden takes over a beachside café on a remote island and hopes for a clean break. Instead she finds witch relatives, hidden feuds, and a murder that will not stay buried.

2

Ghost Writer

by Mara Webb

2021

Sadie is barely adjusting to life in Hallow Haven when another ghostly problem turns into a fresh mystery. The islands have plenty of secrets, and some of them talk back.

3

Give Up The Ghost

by Mara Webb

2021

Halloween should be fun, but Sadie can see disaster coming from every direction. With enemies making moves and spirits stirring, this holiday turns deadly.

4

Haunted Ever After

by Mara Webb

2021

Another brush with the supernatural leaves Sadie balancing island life, relationships, and a fresh investigation. Hallow Haven never stays quiet for long.

5

May Day

by Mara Webb

2021

May Day celebrations should lift the mood in Hallow Haven, but Sadie's personal worries and a new mystery make that impossible. Festival season brings trouble as quickly as it brings flowers.

6

Rags to Witches

by Mara Webb

2021

Sadie is still finding her footing as a witch when another case drags her into island drama and hidden motives. A fresh murder means there is no time to take it slow.

7

Red Letter Witch

by Mara Webb

2021

A direct threat puts Sadie on edge just as people around Hallow Haven start disappearing. Fear spreads fast across the islands, and she may be next.

8

Third Time's A Charm

by Mara Webb

2021

A cold case starts to mirror a recent murder, and Sadie realizes history may be repeating itself. To stop it, she has to connect past and present before the killer strikes again.

9

Witch In The Water

by Mara Webb

2021

With danger circling the islands again, Sadie has to follow a watery trail of clues. The more she learns about Hallow Haven, the less safe it feels.

10

Witch Way Down

by Mara Webb

2021

Sadie throws herself into a new project to avoid hard truths, then lands in the middle of another dangerous case. On Hallow Haven, even distraction comes with ghosts and suspects.

11

Here Comes The Witch

by Mara Webb

2022

Just when Sadie hopes for calmer days, new trouble blows in and puts everyone on alert. Another case forces her deeper into the islands' tangled magical history.

12

New Moon, New Me

by Mara Webb

2022

A new phase in Sadie's life brings fresh magic and fresh complications. When another case surfaces, change becomes the least of her problems.

13

Spell It Out

by Mara Webb

2022

Words, spells, and secrets all matter in Sadie's latest mystery. To protect Hallow Haven, she has to work out which truths the islands have been hiding.

14

The Witch Witness

by Mara Webb

2022

Premonitions, a murder trial, and a dangerous ban on public magic leave Sadie exposed from every angle. The final Hallow Haven case pushes her toward a future that will change everything.

15

Witch Hunt

by Mara Webb

2022

Tension spikes in Hallow Haven as fear, suspicion, and old grudges rise to the surface. Sadie has to solve the latest case before panic does more damage than magic.

Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries books in chronological order

  1. Book cover for "All Wands on Deck"

    All Wands on Deck

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 1
  2. Book cover for "Ghost Writer"

    Ghost Writer

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 2
  3. Book cover for "Witch In The Water"

    Witch In The Water

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 3
  4. Book cover for "Rags to Witches"

    Rags to Witches

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 4
  5. Book cover for "May Day"

    May Day

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 5
  6. Book cover for "Witch Way Down"

    Witch Way Down

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 6
  7. Book cover for "Red Letter Witch"

    Red Letter Witch

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 7
  8. Book cover for "Third Time's A Charm"

    Third Time's A Charm

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 8
  9. Book cover for "Give Up The Ghost"

    Give Up The Ghost

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 9
  10. Book cover for "Haunted Ever After"

    Haunted Ever After

    by Mara Webb

    2021Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 10
  11. Book cover for "New Moon, New Me"

    New Moon, New Me

    by Mara Webb

    2022Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 11
  12. Book cover for "Spell It Out"

    Spell It Out

    by Mara Webb

    2022Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 12
  13. Book cover for "Here Comes The Witch"

    Here Comes The Witch

    by Mara Webb

    2022Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 13
  14. Book cover for "Witch Hunt"

    Witch Hunt

    by Mara Webb

    2022Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 14
  15. Book cover for "The Witch Witness"

    The Witch Witness

    by Mara Webb

    2022Hallow Haven Witch Mysteries, Book 15

Series background & context

Sadie Alden arrives in Hallow Haven hoping to disappear into a new life. She has sold her cafés, boarded a plane, and taken over a beachside café on a remote island where nobody knows her name. That plan lasts about five minutes. The locals know things about Sadie that she does not know herself, and before long she learns she has family on the islands, a connection to witchcraft, and a front-row seat to a lot of old trouble.

The series mixes beach-town charm with a bigger family and magic arc than some of Webb's lighter cozies. Sadie is not just solving murders. She is trying to understand where she fits in a place shaped by feuds, secrets, and the kind of history that refuses to stay in the past. There is a sheriff who keeps his distance, a local protector who appears when things go bad, and more than one ghost with opinions.

Life's a beach, until the haunting starts.

Hallow Haven works well if you like island settings with layers. The books use festivals, holidays, and local events for cozy color, but the ongoing stakes keep building. Sadie has relationships to sort out, powers to understand, and a community that needs her whether she feels ready or not.

It is still a Mara Webb series, so you get humor, mystery, and plenty of supernatural chaos. It just comes with a slightly larger emotional arc running underneath.

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

Comments

Did we miss something? Have feedback?

Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts

We only use your email to notify you about replies.

All comments are moderated.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.