Cullen Tindall Western Mystery Books in Order
Part ofRobert Peecher Books in OrderSee the Cullen Tindall Western Mystery books by Robert Peecher in order, with case summaries, series background, and easy where-to-start guidance.
Last updated: June 8, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Publication Order
5 books
The Blackmail Murders
by Robert Peecher
2019
Sheriff Cullen Tindall and Deputy Emmett Brewer face a case where secrets are as dangerous as gunmen. What begins as blackmail turns into murder, forcing the lawmen to untangle lies before the next body drops.
The Gambler's Losing Hand
by Robert Peecher
2019
When famed gambler and gunfighter Brawling Dick Bloodworth rides into Buffalo Gap, Sheriff Tindall knows trouble has arrived with him. Soon he and Brewer are protecting a man they would rather run out of town.
The Railroad Murder
by Robert Peecher
2019
A killing tied to the railroad puts Cullen Tindall on a trail that runs through money, progress, and hidden grudges. In Buffalo Gap, the promise of the rails brings new suspects and fresh danger.
The Victim and the Bounty Hunter
by Robert Peecher
2019
A young woman is found murdered, a mother cannot find her son, and the town is ready to hang the wrong men. Sheriff Cullen Tindall and Deputy Emmett Brewer have two mysteries to solve before innocent people pay the price.
The Mexican Silver Dollars
by Robert Peecher
2026
When Sheriff Cullen Tindall pulls a body from a burning cabin, he learns the man was shot before the fire ever started. A handful of silver dollars may be the key to both the victim's identity and the killer.
Series background & context
This series takes a classic Western setup and gives it a detective spine. Sheriff Cullen Tindall and Deputy Emmett Brewer keep the peace in Buffalo Gap, but their job is not just chasing rustlers or trading shots in the street. They have to solve murders, untangle lies, and stop townspeople from hanging the wrong man before the facts are in.
That gives the books a nice balance. You still get frontier atmosphere, saloons, gamblers, bounty hunters, railroad trouble, armed men with bad tempers, but the real engine is the case. Each book starts with a crime or a puzzle and then lets Tindall and Brewer work through it like practical lawmen who know that a quick answer is not always the right one.
They are good company.
Tindall is steady without feeling stiff, and Brewer gives the series a second set of eyes and instincts. Together they make the stories feel grounded. These are not fancy drawing-room mysteries dropped into cowboy clothes. They are Western investigations, with dust, fear, and pressure hanging over every decision.
If you want to know what kind of series this is, start with The Blackmail Murders. It sets up the mix of frontier violence and clue-driven storytelling well. From there, books like The Victim and the Bounty Hunter and The Gambler's Losing Hand keep widening the town around them. The appeal is simple, a sheriff, a deputy, a hard place to keep orderly, and one more secret waiting to come loose.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.
Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts