Chasing Evil Trilogy Books in Order

The Chasing Evil Trilogy is Leslie Tentler's darker series, three romantic suspense novels built around serial killer cases and the people pulled into them. Each book has its own central couple and its own investigation, so the connection is more about tone, professional overlap, and emotional intensity than one long continuing plot. What carries across the trilogy is the sense that danger is personal, obsessive, and never far from the main characters' private lives.

The first book, Midnight Caller, sets that mood fast. Rain Sommers is a late-night radio psychologist in New Orleans, used to hearing strange voices in the dark, until one caller becomes fixated on her and on her murdered mother. FBI agent Trevor Rivette believes the caller is tied to a serial killer known as the Vampire, and the story turns into a tense hunt through a city full of heat, shadow, and bad memories.

Midnight Fear shifts the action north, but it keeps the pressure high. Caitlyn Cahill has already paid dearly for helping the FBI connect her brother to a string of murders, and the old case has wrecked both her family life and her sense of safety. When FBI agent Reid Novak arrives to warn her that a copycat may be targeting her, the book becomes a close, uneasy cat-and-mouse game shaped by guilt, political power, and fear that the nightmare is starting again.

Then Edge of Midnight pushes the series into even rougher territory. Reporter Mia Hale is found alive on a Jacksonville beach after escaping a killer called the Collector, but she remembers almost nothing about what happened to her. FBI agent Eric MacFarlane has spent years chasing that case, and Mia's missing memories may be the only path back to the man hunting her. The result is part manhunt, part recovery story, and part race against time.

These are not cozy mysteries.

Tentler leans into trauma, obsession, and the ways violent crime spills into work, family, and love. Her heroines are never just there to be rescued. Rain reads people for a living. Caitlyn has already made one hard, brave choice before her book even opens. Mia survives the worst thing that has ever happened to her and still keeps moving toward the truth. The romances grow out of protection, trust, and shared pressure, which fits the series better than light banter ever could.

The settings help too. New Orleans gives the first book a humid, haunted edge. Washington, D.C., and rural Virginia bring money, family scrutiny, and old scandal into the second. Jacksonville and the Florida coast give the third a stark opening and a different kind of exposure. If you want romantic suspense where the killers are memorable, the investigations feel personal, and the mood stays tense from the first chapter on, this trilogy is where Tentler goes darkest.