9 Best Val McDermid Books
The best Val McDermid books, ranked by how many expert sources recommend each one, with notes to help you choose a series, standalone, or nonfiction read.
Our take
Val McDermid’s crime books range from the violent psychological investigations of Tony Hill and Carol Jordan to Karen Pirie’s Scottish cold cases. Across both series, she asks how investigators distinguish a convincing story from evidence, and how an old crime continues to shape people’s lives. The tone varies: the Tony Hill books are often especially graphic, while the Karen Pirie novels give more room to the social history surrounding a case.
You can also read her without beginning a long police series. A Place of Execution is a standalone built around an investigation revisited decades later. 1979 follows a Glasgow reporter, and Forensics turns to the real specialists whose work underpins crime fiction. Start with The Mermaids Singing for psychological profiling, The Distant Echo for a cold case whose original suspects take center stage, or A Place of Execution for a self-contained mystery.
9 books · 8 sources · Last updated
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Reading Val McDermid in order? See all Val McDermid books in order
How to choose from this list
Skip to the full rankingIf you want psychological profiling: The Mermaids Singing → The Wire in the Blood
If you want to begin Karen Pirie: The Distant Echo → A Darker Domain
If you want a standalone mystery: A Place of Execution
If you prefer reporters to police: 1979
If you want the science behind investigations: Forensics
The 9 books, ranked
Ranked by how many expert sources name each book. Ties go to the book more people recommend.
For newcomers who want a complete mystery without committing to a series. Its two-period structure makes the reliability of an investigation central to the suspense, though the patient village detail delays the bigger revelations.
What it's about
In the winter of 1963, a teenage girl vanishes from an isolated Derbyshire community, and DI George Bennett is sent in to find her. Decades later, a journalist revisits the case—and the story begins to change.
For curious crime readers who want to understand the evidence behind fictional investigations. Its interviews and case histories connect several forensic disciplines, though it offers an accessible overview rather than the depth of a technical manual.
What it's about
Val McDermid’s nonfiction tour of forensic science follows evidence from the crime scene to the courtroom. Along the way, she explains how modern investigators use pathology, DNA, and other tools to let the dead “speak.”
For readers who like cold cases that follow the long damage done by suspicion. It puts the original suspects ahead of detective procedure for much of the book, so Karen Pirie arrives later than series newcomers may expect.
What it's about
In 1978, four students find the body of barmaid Rosie Duff in a snowy graveyard. Twenty-five years later, Detective Karen Pirie reopens the case—and the old secrets still have teeth.
For readers who prefer buried family history and Scottish social tensions to serial-killer profiling. Its interwoven cold cases give Karen Pirie a broader canvas, though the shifts between times and investigations demand attention.
What it's about
A 1984 kidnapping of a wealthy Scottish heiress and her young son ends in death and disappearance. When a clue surfaces decades later in Tuscany, Detective Karen Pirie follows the trail back to Fife and a buried past.
For established Tony Hill and Carol Jordan readers who enjoy pressure on the whole police team. It broadens the focus beyond psychological profiling, but the continuing relationships and fifth-book position make it a less natural starting point.
What it's about
A high-profile death rocks Bradfield and puts Carol Jordan’s unit under intense scrutiny. Tony Hill’s analysis points to motives tangled in power and resentment, where the truth could cost more than either of them can afford.
For returning Karen Pirie readers who enjoy mysteries about the boundary between stories and evidence. Its manuscript-centered puzzle adds a literary rivalry to the cold-case work, though the lockdown setting and ongoing relationships may narrow its appeal.
What it's about
During Scotland’s lockdown, Karen Pirie receives an unfinished crime manuscript that reads like a blueprint for a real disappearance: an Edinburgh University student who never came home. She has to separate fiction from confession before the trail goes cold.
For readers who want to begin with Tony Hill and Carol Jordan. It establishes their uneasy partnership and the profiling approach that drives the series, but its graphic violence makes it a harsh introduction to McDermid.
What it's about
A serial killer is abducting men and leaving grotesque clues behind. DCI Carol Jordan turns to clinical psychologist Tony Hill, whose insights might be the only thing standing between the city and the next killing.
For readers who want McDermid’s investigative instincts in a newsroom rather than a police station. Its period setting makes workplace sexism and reporting part of the mystery, though the historical atmosphere shares space with the suspense.
What it's about
In late-1970s Glasgow, ambitious reporter Allie Burns fights to do real investigations beyond the “women’s pages.” With colleague Danny Sullivan, she follows a lead on tax fraud that grows into a bigger, riskier story.
Also recommended by
1 person
Nicola Sturgeon recommended this bookNicola Sturgeon
"Outstanding." - Nicola Sturgeon
Nicola Sturgeon's recommendation of this book
For readers continuing the Tony Hill series who want a closer look at profiling and public respectability. It builds on the first book’s partnership, but the cruelty remains intense and makes this a poor choice for gentler mystery tastes.
What it's about
Women are snatched, brutalized, and left alive—until the next one isn’t so lucky. Tony Hill and Carol Jordan race to build a profile of a predator who thrives on fear, while the pressure to stop him turns personal.
Sources
- 1
Books by Val McDermid
valmcdermid.com
- 2
Val McDermid
fantasticfiction.com
- 3
Val McDermid Books in Order
mysterysequels.com
- 4
Val Mcdermid
reddit.com
- 5
What’s a good Val McDermid book
reddit.com
- 6
Books by Val McDermid (Author of The Mermaids Singing)
goodreads.com
- 7
Val McDermid
crimebooks.uk
- 8
Best Val McDermid Books: These are the 10 best novels by the Scottish crime writer - according to readers
scotsman.com
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shape MRB and its growth.
Comments
Spotted a missing book, a wrong order or a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix this page.
We're a reading guide, not the author or publisher, so we can't send books or pass on messages.