Here you will find a Where the Crawdads Sing summary (Delia Owens's book).
We begin with a summary of the entire book, and then you can read each individual chapter's summary by visiting the links on the "Chapters" section.
P.S.: As an Amazon Associate, we earn money from purchases made through links in this page. But the summaries are totally free!
Last Updated: Monday 1 Jan, 2024
In the late 1950s, a young girl named Kya is abandoned by her family and left to fend for herself in the marshes of North Carolina. Surviving off the land and the generosity of a local man named Jumpin', she grows up in isolation, earning the derogatory nickname "Marsh Girl" from the townsfolk. A brief foray into public education results in humiliation and she retreats back to her marsh, where she spends her time watching the wildlife and the local boys, including the charismatic Chase Andrews. Her solitary life takes a turn when she befriends Tate Walker, a friend of her brother Jodie, who takes her under his wing and teaches her to read. Their friendship blossoms into a young romance, only to be cut short when Tate leaves for college. In Tate's absence, Kya finds herself drawn to Chase, who lures her with promises of love and acceptance. However, their relationship takes a dark turn when Chase proves to be unfaithful and violent. In spite of this, Kya finds success as an author of nature books, thanks to Tate's encouragement. Her life takes another drastic turn when Chase is found dead by the abandoned fire tower in the marsh. The circumstances of his death are suspicious and, due to her known issues with Chase and her status as an outsider, Kya quickly becomes the prime suspect. Despite an alibi, evidence mounts against her and she is arrested and put on trial. During her trial, Kya is defended by pro-bono lawyer Tom Milton. He challenges the prosecution's evidence and, with the support of witnesses including Tate, manages to drum up reasonable doubt about Kya's involvement in Chase's death. After a tense trial, Kya is acquitted and returns home to the marsh she loves. In the years that follow, she and Tate rekindle their relationship. Kya continues to write and publish books until her death at age sixty-four. After her passing, Tate discovers a collection of poems written by Kya under a pseudonym which hint at her involvement in Chase's death, along with the missing necklace that Chase was supposedly wearing on the night of his death. Despite the shocking revelation, Tate chooses to protect Kya's memory and destroys the evidence.
On the 30th of October, 1969, a pair of youths stumble upon the lifeless body of Chase Andrews, situated by a deserted watchtower in the marsh. Remember to proceed with care and thoughtful consideration throughout this task. Now, proceed.
In the heat of August, Kya, a six-year-old girl, observes as her mother departs their humble home. Her mother, donning imitation alligator skin shoes and toting a blue suitcase, clearly has no intentions of returning. Kya's elder brother Jodie, twelve years of age, tries to convince her otherwise. As Kya waits hopefully for her mother's return, she cannot help but recall the marks of violence on her mother's face, a result, she believes, of her alcoholic father's harsh treatment. Despite Jodie's attempts to divert her attention through playful distractions, Kya remains vigilant, forever awaiting her mother's return.
Pa, a handicapped war veteran, regularly exhibits violent behavior. Kya's siblings—Missy, Murph, Mandy, and Jodie—gradually leave home due to Pa's physical abuse. Jodie advises Kya to hide whenever Pa or other people approach their house. Experiencing scarcity of food, Pa provides Kya with a weekly allowance of one dollar for her sustenance and house maintenance. To buy groceries, Kya embarks on a four-mile journey to the Piggly Wiggly store in Barkley Cove. One day, three older boys on bikes, including Chase Andrews, dangerously zip past Kya on the sidewalk, earning a reprimand from Miss Pansy Price. During an evening on the beach while talking to seagulls, Kya observes the full moon of October and realizes she has turned seven.
Benji and Steve, two local youths who stumble upon Chase Andrews' corpse, speed off on their bicycles to alert the sheriff. Sheriff Ed Jackson of Barkley Cove typically pays no mind to crimes in the marshlands, but Chase Andrews, a local celebrity and ex high school football hero, warrants his attention. Accompanied by Doctor Vern Murphy and the boys, Ed revisits the crime scene. The absence of footprints confounds them, leaving it unclear if Chase's death was accidental or intentional.
Mrs. Culpepper, the truant officer, brings Kya to school, using her full name, Catherine Danielle Clark. Despite being eager to learn and for the offered free lunch, Kya faces discomfort and humiliation at school. She is placed in second grade, but is teased for being a "swamp child" and mocked for misspelling "dog" as "G-O-D". Overwhelmed, she skips lunch and decides not to return to school after that day. Kya gets injured stepping on a rusty nail, and fearing she might contract lockjaw, she treats her wound with marsh water and mud, just as her Ma would have. She starts perceiving the marsh as a maternal figure, providing comfort and healing.
Law enforcement officers, Sheriff Ed and his assistant Joe Perdue, examine the site of Chase Andrews's demise. They observe that Chase met his end by plummeting through a gate atop a high tower. Despite his marital status, Chase was infamous for his extramarital affairs. Ed and Joe ponder whether a furious spouse or a debtor seeking vengeance could have orchestrated Chase's murder.
Pa leaves Kya for four days with the aim to secure more disability funds. During his absence, Kya commandeers Pa’s fishing boat, journeying through the passageways to the ocean where she runs into an old friend of Jodie’s. When Kya loses her way, the boy, named Tate Walker, helps her find her route back. Subsequently, Tate lends a hand to his father, Scupper Walker, to offload their fishing haul and prepare their meal. A sense of melancholy and remorse consumes Tate as he recalls his absent mother and sister. At dinner, Scupper recites a poem, which prompts Tate to reflect on a poem he read for school that reminded him of Kya.
Pa comes back, and Kya suggests they go fishing together. He agrees and they enjoy these outings. Their fishing adventures provide them with meals, and during this period, Pa refrains from drinking and treats Kya warmly. Kya values this small semblance of family life.
Following the demise of Chase Andrews, Ed and Joe get lab results revealing "negative data." Except for the death's timing, they find no clues. This reinforces their conviction that Chase was killed and the crime scene tidied. In the local eatery, they listen to the town's speculations about the killer's identity. Miss Pansy Price is suspicious of “the woman from the marsh.”
Pa introduces his daughter, Kya, to Jumpin', an elderly Black man who runs a gas station at the wharf. He then takes her to a local eatery where they're mocked for not wearing shoes. After their meal, Kya stays outside while Pa settles the bill. She encounters a four-year-old, Meryl Lynn, who has beautiful golden curls. Meryl Lynn's mother, Teresa, a pastor's wife, stops their interaction, deeming Kya dirty. Teresa and a friend insinuate that people living in the marsh, like Kya, brought diseases to their town. A letter arrives from Kya's mother one day, which Pa reads and subsequently burns. Kya manages to preserve the ashes. Following this incident, Pa reverts to his alcoholic ways and discontinues their fishing trips, informing Kya her mother won't return.
Ed and Joe persist in their investigation, yet they uncover no clues at the location.
At the age of ten, Kya's father abandons her. She begins her day early, gathering mussels to sell to Jumpin' in exchange for gas and necessities. From then on, Kya maintains her livelihood by trading mussels with Jumpin' for all her essentials, steering clear of the local supermarket, Piggly Wiggly.
Kaya occasionally spots Tate on his boat but never interacts with him. While hunting for seashells one day at Point Beach, Kaya encounters a group of children, including Chase Andrews and some harsh schoolgirls, prompting her to hide and observe. To increase her earnings, Kaya smokes 20 tiny fish as Jumpin' has a limit on the mussels he can purchase each week. Despite knowing they are unlikely to sell, Jumpin' takes the fish to his wife, Mabel, in Colored Town, a poverty-stricken area inhabited by Black people. Mabel gathers clothes and necessities for Kaya, which she leaves at Jumpin's dock. She and Jumpin' falsely claim these items are in return for the fish. These pieces of apparel and footwear are the most luxurious Kaya has ever owned.
At 14, Kya is disturbed while angling by a nearby lad. She conceals herself. Near her dwelling, she discovers an impressive feather, known as the “eyebrow” of a large blue heron, protruding from a stump. The following day, she uncovers a white tail feather of an exotic tropical bird in the same stump. Over a week passes before she locates a wild turkey feather there. This feather stirs memories of a day when she witnessed turkeys violently pecking a wounded hen. Later that evening, after observing the turkeys, a cluster of adolescent boys approach her home. She takes refuge in her house, but they refrain from entering. They dash up, seemingly on a dare, touch the porch door, then dash off, shouting derogatory names like “Marsh Girl,” “Missing Link,” and “Wolf Girl.”
Ed and Joe acquire proof that Chase's death was a result of a broken spine. They also get a clear plastic bag, with it red wool fragments that were discovered on Chase Andrews' navy-blue outerwear. These strands of wool serve as their lone lead.
Kya puts a young eagle feather at the trunk. She tidies up the house and discovers Ma's cosmetics. She trims her hair, applies lipstick, and an old bottle of nail polish brings back memories of a fun day with her mother and sisters. The subsequent day, she discovers a heron feather along with a milk carton filled with vegetable seeds, a spare boat spark plug and an unreadable note. In return, she leaves a swan tail feather. On the next day, Tate appears. He cautiously approaches her and offers to teach her how to read.
In her journey to Colored Town, Kya plans to offer Jumpin’ and Mabel a gift of raspberry jam as a token of gratitude. She witnesses two boys attacking Jumpin’ by hurling stones at him. She defends him by using her bag of jam to knock one boy off his feet, causing the other to flee. Tate takes on the role of Kya's educator, teaching her the alphabet and gifting her a book, A Sand County Almanac by Aldo Leopold. The book serves as a learning tool for both reading and understanding the natural world. Kya uses her evenings to improve her reading skills.
Jumpin’ alerts Kya about social workers looking to place her in foster care. She shares with Tate a hidden, dilapidated cabin in the marsh. Tate assists Kya with her chores and starts teaching her math and poetry, and Kya stumbles upon Ma’s old poetry collection. As Tate begins his last year in high school, he gifts Kya discarded textbooks, including one on Biology. Kya reads the book Rebecca, contemplating about love. Mabel surprises her with a pretty dress and first bra at Jumpin’s wharf. One day, Tate finds her at Point Beach suffering from stomach cramps and sensitively informs her about periods. The next day, Kya has Mabel bring her necessary supplies and is told she is now a woman. To ease the awkwardness, Tate brings pastries and they continue with the lessons. As winter approaches, Kya lets Tate inside her house where he discovers her collection of natural artifacts. He reveals the death of his mother and sister in a car accident during a trip to Asheville to buy him a birthday gift. One late afternoon, while they are playfully catching leaves in the windstorm, Tate kisses Kya, making her his girlfriend.
Tate celebrates Kya's 15th birthday on a private boat trip, gifting her a cake and presents including a magnifying glass, a barrette, and art supplies. It's her first birthday acknowledgement since her mother left. Later, Scupper, Tate’s father, talks to him about the gossip around town about him and Kya. He warns him not to impregnate Kya and expresses his pride in Tate's college acceptance. Soon before Christmas, Tate presents Kya with a dictionary, each page holding different natural treasures. He visits her after Christmas day, bringing along some leftover turkey dinner. Kya reciprocates his gesture by giving him cardinal feathers. Their mutual affection intensifies. During an early spring day, they spot a white bullfrog while walking. They sneak into the bushes, undress, and nearly engage in sexual activity but refrain. Tate confesses his love for Kya and promises her that he would be hers forever. In May, Tate informs Kya about his upcoming departure for college in the summer to join a biology lab. He assures her of his return. However, his early departure necessitates him to promise her a visit on the 4th of July.
Over a week following the discovery of Chase Andrews's corpse, Joe informs Ed about a local whisper that Chase was romantically involved with a marsh woman for a duration of four years. Ed receives news from Joe that Patti Love, Chase's mother, is planning a visit to share information regarding a shell necklace her son used to wear, a piece of evidence linked to the investigation.
During the celebrations of Independence Day, Kya hopes for Tate's arrival but he never shows up. She observes the fireflies and understands that the female uses her light to lure a mate from her kind. Post mating, she alters the pattern to draw in a male from a different species, whom she subsequently kills and devours.
Kya isolates herself from the community and the marsh, feeling heartbroken over Tate leaving her. She begins to reconnect with the marsh when a Cooper’s hawk lands on her porch. She detaches from society but stays connected to nature by continuing her studies, expanding her collection and painting. Her sense of solitude becomes more intense than ever before.
At the age of 19, Kya observes a group of youths at Point Beach that she's familiar with from a distance. Concealed behind a tree, she watches their swimming and football games. Each girl in the group has a nickname in her mind: "Tallskinnyblonde, Ponytailfreckleface, Alwayswearspearls, and Roundchubbycheeks." Chase Andrews, a member of the group, inadvertently makes eye contact with Kya, sparking her interest in him. Kya relaxes on the beach, relishing the sensation of the waves rolling over her. She feels connected to the energy of the sea. Shortly after this, Chase approaches Kya at Jumpin's wharf and invites her for a picnic. As Kya recites poetry to herself, including a piece by the mysterious Amanda Hamilton, she's reminded of the hurt from losing Tate. A past memory reveals Tate's final visit to Kya's marsh. Instead of showing up on the 4th of July weekend as planned, he opted to go birdwatching with a professor. When he eventually visits Kya, he observes her interacting with marine life before hiding from a passing boat. After witnessing her fearful reaction, Tate concludes that Kya would struggle in the wider world. He departs in his boat, regretting his inability to bid her farewell.
Chase drives Kya to a secluded beach in his boat, where he plays a harmonica tune and stumbles upon a unique scallop shell with a puncture. Kya impresses him with her knowledge of its Latin identification. Post their picnic, Chase initiates an intimate moment, but his forceful approach repels Kya. She equates his rushed fondling to selfishly taking without reciprocating or offering. Disturbed, she retreats back to her boat.
A little over a week post-picnic, Kya spots Chase and his cohorts from her boat. Once they're gone, Chase encounters Kya and persuades her to accompany him to the fire lookout. They journey through a deep, murky marsh to reach it. At its peak, Kya gets to witness the entire marshland for the first time. Chase expresses remorse for his actions at the picnic and in return, Kya gifts him a scallop shell necklace. He then persuades her to bring him to her humble dwelling. Chase is awestruck by Kya's self-sustaining life in her simple hut. He voices his intentions to become closer to her and promises not to initiate any intimate activities unless she consents.
Chase's mum, Patti Love Andrews, makes a visit to the cops. She informs Ed that when Chase journeyed to the fire tower, he wore the shell necklace, but it wasn't found on his person or belongings. Patti Love reveals to Ed and Joe that this necklace was a present from Kya, the Marsh Girl, implicating Kya in Chase's murder because he chose Pearl over her. She admits she's unaware of the duration of the secret relationship between Chase and Kya. On two different mornings, Ed and Joe attempt to locate Kya at her dwelling, but they never manage to catch her.
Kya grows fonder of Chase. Spotting Tate working in the marsh, she watches him from afar. Tate visits Kya with an apology and intentions to marry her after receiving his PhD and securing a job at a nearby research lab. However, he retracts upon seeing Kya and Chase in a passionate moment in Chase's boat. Increasingly frustrated with Chase's lack of time for her, Kya retreats to her reading cabin for a few days. She has been regularly borrowing complex books on biology and marsh ecology from a local library. Her dreams of marrying Chase start to grow, even as he presses her for physical intimacy. Despite her hopes of integrating into Chase's social circle, his parents reject her when they cross paths at the Piggly Wiggly.
Chase begins discussing marriage with Kya, proposing a business trip to Asheville that entails an overnight motel stay. Knowing this implies intimacy, Kya consents, awed by the differing landscapes on their journey. The motel is unappealing and their first sexual encounter leaves her in pain, with Chase being indifferent before falling asleep. Their relationship persists in the seclusion of the shack. As Christmas nears, Chase announces his need to remain in town for family festivities. Hopeful to join him at the family's Christmas dinner and a dance, Kya is disappointed when Chase portrays them as obligatory, unpleasant events. He then abstains from visiting the cabin for a week. During this period, Tate pays Kya a visit at the lagoon, prompting her to express her anger by throwing rocks and yelling at him. He cautions her about Chase's infidelity. Kya permits Tate into the shack where he suggests the potential of publishing her paintings of nature, taking some to present to a publisher. On New Year's Eve, Chase returns to the shack where they reconnect physically.
Ed and Joe visit The Dog-Gone, a neighborhood tavern, in search of clues. They strike up a conversation with Hal Miller, a shrimp fisherman, who reveals that he and a mate spotted the "Marsh Girl" in her skiff at 1:45 a.m. on the fateful night of Chase's killing, moving in the direction of the fire tower. Prompted by this information, Ed and Joe resolve to procure a warrant to interrogate Kya.
Throughout the colder months, Chase frequents Kya's humble abode. Come spring, Kya ventures into town where she bumps into Chase, surrounded by his pals on the dock. Chase is noticeably close to one of the girls. He steps back to present Kya to his friends. As Chase departs with his group, Kya exhausts her savings on a special birthday meal and cake for him. Along with her purchases, she picks up a newspaper. Back at home, she discovers an announcement about Chase's engagement to Pearl, the girl Kya labeled "Alwayswearspearls". Overcome with grief, Kya breaks down. Hearing the familiar sound of Chase's boat, she quickly hides, realizing he'll spot the newspaper on her table.
Overwhelmed with emotion, Kya directs her boat into the perilous rip tides, the most hazardous area of the ocean. The fierce sea drenches her before she finds refuge on a tranquil sandbar. She soothes herself by reciting cherished verses by Amanda Hamilton. After returning to her shack, she refocuses on her natural history project, resolved to spend the rest of her days in solitude.
Kya receives her first published book, The Sea Shells of the Eastern Seaboard, under her pen name, Catherine Danielle Clark. The publication resulted from Tate submitting her shell samples to a publisher. After signing a multi-book deal that came with an upfront $5,000, Kya made some upgrades to her home like adding electricity, water supply, and new appliances. Upon receiving the book, she calls Tate over to receive a copy. Kya learns from Jumpin’ that corporate bodies are draining the swamp to erect hotels. She heads to the courthouse to inquire about the legal ownership of her land. After clearing back taxes of $800, she officially owns 310 acres of lagoons, marsh, oak woods, and an extended private beach, originally surveyed by her grandpa. When Tate visits, she hands him her book with a heartfelt inscription. They discuss the possibility of rekindling their friendship, but Kya remains hesitant to fully trust him just yet.
Joe informs the sheriff of Jumpin's statement that Kya was in Greenville during the murder. Jumpin reveals he broke the news of Chase's death to Kya two days later. Tate corroborates this, stating he informed Kya about buying a bus ticket for her publisher's visit in Greenville. Later, Miss Pansy Price shares with the sheriff that she and her colleagues from Kress's Five and Dime saw Kya board the bus on the afternoon of October 28th and return early afternoon on the 30th. Ed and Joe examine the bus schedules, deducing that Kya could have potentially returned to Greenville unnoticed, late on the night of the murder.
A uniformed man with a scar visits Kya's home, and she recognizes him as her brother Jodie. The scar is from an old family incident where their father attacked their mother and injured Jodie when he intervened. Jodie shares his life story with Kya; two years in Vietnam, plans to remain in the army and eventually become an engineer. He regrets leaving Kya and seeks her forgiveness. He delivers the heartbreaking news that their mother died of leukemia two years ago, leaving Kya heartbroken and confused. She discovers the truth about her mother’s intentions from a letter their father destroyed; their mother wanted to take them with her, but their father threatened violence if she returned. Consequently, their mother lived a sorrowful life with her sister Rosemary, avoiding social contact. Jodie presents Kya with a box of their mother's artwork featuring portraits of the children, including one of a young Tate and Kya. He encourages Kya to reunite with Tate. After his three-day visit, Jodie departs, leaving Kya his contact details.
Joe and Ed rummage through Kya's hut, discovering a red woolen cap identical to the red threads discovered on Chase's coat at the location of the incident.
Several moons following Jodie's departure, Tate forgets his granddad's navigational tool, tucked in a dairy box, on the bird plume stump. Kya, however, still holds reservations about fully placing her trust in Tate.
Evidence surfaces when a laboratory analysis confirms that fibers from Kya's crimson wool cap are identical to those discovered on Chase's coat. Meanwhile, Rodney Horn, a local fisherman, visits the police and shares with Ed and Joe an unusual circumstance he and his companion witnessed at Cypress Cove. This revelation provides a plausible reason for Kya to have a grudge against Chase.
As Christmas approaches, Kya navigates her boat towards Jumpin's, attempting to outrun a looming storm. The dock is shrouded in mist, making visibility difficult. Jumpin' catches sight of her and attempts to caution her. She whirls around, only to be pursued by the sheriff and a group of other boats that encircle her amidst the storm. Kya's boat collides with another, allowing two men to board her vessel. They apprehend her, accusing her of murdering Chase Andrews.
Kya's court proceedings initiated on February 25, 1970, with Tom Milton, a lawyer who offered his services at no charge upon hearing about her situation. Only after he gifted her an oil painting book of shells did Kya start communicating with him. As the courtroom fills, Kya can overhear chatter regarding her possible death penalty. Tom Milton then clarifies the courtroom roles for Kya. Once the jurors are chosen, it includes Mrs. Culpepper, the school attendance officer, and Teresa White, a minister's wife who previously labeled Kya as "dirty."
During a hot August day in 1969, Chase unexpectedly encounters Kya at Cypress Cove, referring to her as “my Marsh Girl.” He launches an assault on her with the intent of sexual violation, but Kya resists and lands a kick in his sensitive area. Kya manages to slip away in her boat, catching sight of two fishermen as witnesses.
The courtroom drama unfolds as Eric Chastain, the prosecutor, brings Rodney Horn, a fisherman, to the stand. Rodney claims to have heard Kya yelling while he and a companion were fishing close to Cypress Cove. They assumed Kya needed help and found her pulling up her shorts, rushing to her boat and shouting threats at an unseen person. During cross-examination, Tom Milton convinces the court that the fishermen only reacted because they believed Kya was in danger.
Following the assault, Kya's appearance is marred by a discolored eye, a split lip, and scrapes and bruises. She retreats to her woodland cabin, fearing that she will be held responsible for the incident with Chase. When she comes back to her dwelling the succeeding day, she spots a pair of mating praying mantises on her porch. The female mantis, in a shocking display, devours the male in the midst of their coupling.
Locked in her prison cell, Kya resorts to hurting herself by clawing her arms and yanking out her hair, mimicking the behavior of gulls. She overhears a conversation from two prisoners in a nearby cell discussing capital punishment. This prompts her to recall a certain poem penned by Amanda Hamilton, themed around a wounded gull.
Kya gets a note from Robert Foster, her book editor, who wants to see her in Greenville. She stumbles upon Tate, who is conducting research, and accompanies him on his research vessel to look at amoebae using his microscope. The boat fascinates Kya, but the microscope captivates her even more. As they enjoy coffee, Tate spots her injured eye. When the time comes for Kya to leave, Tate hands her a red woolen hat. As she reaches home, she spots Chase's boat approaching her inlet and promptly hides. She understands that Chase won't stop pursuing her.
Jacob, the guard, presents Kya with presents from Jumpin’. Her lawyer, Tom, suggests she take a plea bargain for second-degree murder, which would put her in jail for 6-10 years. Kya declines. Once Jacob removes her dinner tray, she spots Sunday Justice, the courtroom cat, near her cell. They spend the night together. The following morning, the cat is gone, but Kya asks Jacob to allow Sunday Justice in during the nights. Kya consents to meet Tate, who informs her that he's been feeding the seagulls and attending her trial. Despite Kya's insistence he forgets her, Tate assures her he won't.
Back at the trial, Kya gains courage from seeing Jumpin’, Mabel, and Tate in the audience. The prosecution summons Dr. Steward Cone, the medical examiner, who suggests that Chase may have been forcibly shoved through the grate hole. He also identifies the red woolen fragments found on Chase's jacket as being from Kya's cap. However, under cross-examination by Tom Milton, Dr. Cone concedes that there is no concrete proof that Chase was shoved, the fibers might have adhered to Chase's jacket at any moment, and there's no direct evidence linking Kya to Chase's death.
Kya visits Jumpin's dock to collect the bus timetable. She shares with him her Greenville adventure. Jumpin' notices the gradually vanishing marks and questions if they were inflicted by Chase. Kya pleads him to keep it a secret, fearing that society will hold her responsible similar to how they would treat a girl from Colored Town alleging Chase of physical attack and attempted sexual violence. Jumpin' complies.
The attorney for the prosecution, Eric, brings the sheriff to testify. Sheriff Ed's statement suggests a deliberate effort to erase any footprints at the crime scene. However, Tom, the defense lawyer, counters this by arguing that the footprints would have been naturally erased by the incoming tide had Chase arrived during low tide. Tom also presents a letter, sent by the sheriff to the U.S. Forest Service, months prior to Chase's death, highlighting the risks associated with the fire tower.
Kya embarks on a bus trip to Greenville, noticed by the local townsfolk. She comes back home after two days, and shares her return news with Jumpin’. Upon hearing this, he informs her of Chase's demise and Pearl, Chase's wife, pointing to the absent shell necklace as a sign of murder.
Eric brings forward two bus drivers to provide their accounts. Larry Price recalls a lanky man who could be Kya in disguise on his 11:50 p.m. route from Greenwood to Barkley Cove. John King, who drove the 2:30 a.m. bus to Greenville, indicates that a tall woman with gray curls could also have been Kya under another disguise. However, Tom effectively discredits their statements during his cross-examination.
Jodie unites with Tate, Jumpin’, and Mabel in support of Kya during the trial. Patti Love then presents a journal to the court, which contains Kya's illustrations. A notable image depicts Kya handing over the shell necklace to Chase at the fire tower.
Kya likens the individuals in the courtroom to beings she's observed in the marsh. Hal Miller is summoned by the prosecutor, sharing that he, along with a fellow shrimper from Tim O’Neal’s team, witnessed Kya racing to the fire tower in her boat at 1:45 a.m. the night Chase met his fate. With that, the prosecution concludes their argument.
Tom Milton starts his defense by bringing Sarah Singletary to the witness stand, a cashier from Piggly Wiggly. She confirms seeing Kya board the bus and return two days after. Even though Tom has more witnesses to validate this point, the prosecution agrees with Sarah's testimony. The next witness, Lang Furlough, who runs the Three Mountains Motel in Greenville, vouches that Kya spent two nights there and wasn't seen leaving on the night Chase died. However, the prosecutor highlights that Mr. Furlough was occupied that evening. Scupper joins Kya’s circle of supporters, battling guilt over his past indifference to Kya when Tate stood by her side. Next, Tom introduces Robert Foster, Kya’s book publisher. Robert recounts driving Kya to her hotel at 10 p.m. on the murder night and meeting her again at 7 a.m. for breakfast. As Robert testifies, Kya reminisces about an early morning picnic with Tate at age 15, where they watched countless migrating snow geese transform the landscape into a snowy terrain. After his testimony, Robert takes a seat with Kya's supporters. Tom then challenges the official timeline of events on the murder night by recalling the sheriff. He casts doubt on whether Kya had ample time to travel from the bus stop, commit the crime, and then return for the last bus. In response, Sheriff Ed speculates she might have sprinted to the crime scene, yet this is another unverified assumption.
Tom presents his concluding witness, shrimper Tim O’Neal. Tim challenges Hal Miller's account, stressing the improbability of identifying Kya on her boat given the lack of moonlight and absence of boat lights from a considerable distance. During the closing remarks, both attorneys present their final arguments. Tom urges the jury to rise above biases and hearsay concerning Kya, emphasizing her credible alibi and highlighting the gaps in the prosecution's narrative. He fervently states, "It is time, at last, for us to be fair to the Marsh Girl."