Witch Myth Cozy Mystery Books in Order
Part ofAlexandria Clarke Books in OrderSee the Witch Myth Cozy Mystery books by Alexandria Clarke in order, with summaries, subseries notes, and easy advice on where to start.
Last updated: June 9, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Publication Order
5 books
Lost Magic
by Alexandria Clarke
2019
Magic starts slipping out of reach in this connected Witch Myth mystery. As power, loyalty, and old secrets collide, the people tied to Yew Hollow face a threat they cannot solve the usual way.
Siren Song
by Alexandria Clarke
2019
Bay Bridges tries to stop a woman from being drugged and ends up pulled into supernatural trouble of her own. With a dead man refusing to stay dead, Bay's secret magic becomes harder to hide.
Wild Fire
by Alexandria Clarke
2019
Kennedy's fight does not end when she reaches Yew Hollow. Separated from the person she most wants to protect, she is forced deeper into magic, exile, and the darker rules behind the town.
Witch Myth Christmas
by Alexandria Clarke
2019
Noelle Summers loves Christmas until someone turns the holiday into a magical trap. Stuck in a repeating Christmas and facing a threat to Yew Hollow's children, she has to break the spell fast.
Yew Hollow
by Alexandria Clarke
2019
When her younger sister vanishes, Kennedy McGrath follows an eerie bond into the strange town of Yew Hollow. There she finds witches, dangerous secrets, and a choice that may change her life for good.
Series background & context
The Witch Myth books are really a connected magical neighborhood rather than one narrow storyline, and that is what makes them fun to browse. Different subseries focus on different heroines, but the larger feel stays the same: witches trying to live ordinary lives, ghosts and secrets refusing to stay quiet, and small communities where magic is never quite as hidden as everyone hopes.
Yew Hollow is the heart of it. It is a place where witches and mortals live side by side, family history matters, and trouble has a habit of turning personal very fast. Morgan Summers, Kennedy McGrath, Noelle Summers, and Bay Bridges each pull the world in a slightly different direction. One story may feel like a cozy ghost mystery, another like a missing-person fantasy, another like urban paranormal suspense. The shared appeal is the mix of mystery, magic, and family mess.
That family piece matters a lot. Clarke does not build these books around abstract spells. She builds them around cousins, sisters, estranged parents, mentors, and people who inherit trouble along with power. Magic can solve some problems, but it also creates them. That is why the tone stays grounded even when the plots involve covens, sirens, ghosts, or a Christmas time loop.
The series also has a nice range. The Yew Hollow books feel the most small-town and cozy. The Wild Fire thread gets darker and more urgent because it is driven by a sister's disappearance and the cost of exile. The Siren Song books move into a more urban, faster paranormal register. The Christmas books are playful on the surface and still manage to raise the stakes.
If you like witch mysteries that are more about character and place than elaborate lore dumps, this is a good fit. The books are easy to read on their own, but they reward anyone who enjoys seeing a shared magical world from more than one angle. Cozy is the label, but the emotions underneath can get surprisingly sharp.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.
Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts