Wayfair Witches Cozy Mystery Books in Order
Part ofAA Albright Books in OrderBrowse the Wayfair Witches Cozy Mystery books by AA Albright in order, with short summaries, series background, and help choosing where to start.
Last updated: June 8, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Publication Order
15 books
A Trick for a Treat
by AA Albright
2017
Wanda's Halloween is derailed by a missing famous werewolf and a string of murders that put her own friends under suspicion. She must clear them fast, while still surviving more magical tests.
Bottling It
by AA Albright
2017
Nearly twenty-one and still without powers, Wanda takes a job at a bottling company just as humans across Dublin start murdering witches. To stop it, she may have to embrace the magical life she has been avoiding.
Bricking It
by AA Albright
2017
Wanda finally has her powers, but magical law sends her back to school and bans her from using them. That becomes a real problem when witches start vanishing and skeletons appear across Ireland.
Winging It
by AA Albright
2017
A cluster of apparent suicides leads Wanda to Plimpton's Brooms and the biggest broom race in the witching world. She is chasing a killer, a missing witch, and the truth about her own broom.
Wrapping Up
by AA Albright
2017
When a popular witch is found strangled with festive ribbon and wrapped like a present, Wanda faces a holiday murder with awkward suspects. She needs answers before the Winter Solstice celebrations begin.
Acting Up
by AA Albright
2018
A killer is stalking the set of Be My Witch, and Wanda is rattled because her vision showed a different victim. She has to outrun prophecy and solve the case before the next body drops.
Legally Red
by AA Albright
2018
Melissa Wayfair takes a legal clerkship with the most unbearable lawyer in witchdom and promptly lands in a murder case. Between a troubled young witch and her own broken heart, staying afloat will not be easy.
Loved Up
by AA Albright
2018
Spring celebrations begin with Nancy Berry's murder, and Wanda thinks the Dark Team is behind it. As she closes in on the truth, a possible love potion leaves the Wayfair women feeling very unlike themselves.
Rocking Out
by AA Albright
2018
Two dead superfans put werewolf band The Call of the Wild in the spotlight for all the wrong reasons. Wanda dives into supernatural rock and roll, where murdered familiars make the case even darker.
Swotting Up
by AA Albright
2018
College life gets deadly when a body turns up in the library. Wanda must solve the murder and track down a terrifying Bad, Bad Book before something ancient and dangerous breaks loose.
All Hallowed Out
by AA Albright
2019
Halloween is coming, and witches are being murdered or put into an unnatural sleep. Wanda must track a dangerous spell back to a disappearing novel before the whole world changes for good.
Forget Me Knot
by AA Albright
2019
Wanda wakes in a too-perfect version of Riddler's Cove where she has no magic and everything feels wrong. When healers are murdered and weredogs go missing, she has to uncover who has twisted the world out of shape.
Holiday Heist
by AA Albright
2019
Melissa faces a harpy attack, a young weredog in trouble, and mysterious Solstice plans from the Nemo Foundation kids. To get through it all, she may have to trust the one person she can barely stand.
Doing Time
by AA Albright
2020
After killing Baldrick Berry, Wanda lands in Witchfield Prison with enemies all around her. Inmate deaths and an angry ghost soon make her suspect that Baldrick's death was not as simple as it looked.
All Tricked Out
by AA Albright
2021
A white rabbit asks Wanda to find a missing magician, which sounds simple until murder enters the picture. The clues lead her into the Magic Hat, a strange club on an even stranger unnamed street.
Series background & context
The main Wayfair Witches books center on Wanda Wayfair, a young witch who begins the series still waiting for her powers and doing her best to ignore coven life. Bottling It throws that plan out fast, because witches across Dublin are being attacked and Wanda is pulled into the middle of it. What starts as one young woman's reluctant return to magic becomes a long-running paranormal mystery series with family drama, romance, magical law, and a steady body count.
Wanda does not get a quiet life.
One of the pleasures of these books is that the world feels busy without becoming hard to follow. There are covens, magical officials, familiars, weredogs, werewolves, vampires, colleges, race events, and holiday festivals, but the stories stay rooted in Wanda's point of view. She keeps running into cases that are both local and strange, from disappearing witches and suspicious deaths to cursed books and murders wrapped in festive ribbon.
The series has a cozy rhythm, but it also carries a real ongoing arc. Wanda is not just solving separate mysteries. She is learning how her powers work, figuring out her place in the Wayfair coven, and dealing with the people around her, especially Will Berry and the wider Berry family. Questions about magical law, loyalty, and dangerous magical objects keep building from one novel to the next.
Family is a big part of the appeal. So is community. Even when Wanda is annoyed, outnumbered, or stuck somewhere she absolutely does not want to be, she is rarely handling the mess entirely alone. Her circle shifts and grows across the books, and the supporting cast gives the series a lot of its warmth.
The jokes land, even when the crimes are serious.
If you like cozy mysteries with witches, but want more than a simple village setup, this series has plenty to offer. It mixes magical bureaucracy with friendship and romance, and it is happy to swerve from a college library to a bar, a prison, or a holiday celebration if that is where the mystery leads. Loved Up, Swotting Up, Forget Me Knot, All Hallowed Out, and Doing Time show how comfortable the series is getting bigger while still keeping Wanda at the center.
The best way to think about the Wayfair Witches books is as one connected magical world with murders inside it. There is always a fresh case, but the real hook is watching Wanda grow from a reluctant late bloomer into someone her coven depends on. If you want cozy fantasy mysteries with lots of recurring characters and a strong ongoing story, this is a very easy series to settle into.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

































Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts