St. Lawrence County Amish Books in Order

This series is set in an Amish community in northern New York, and it works best if you like relationship-driven stories where family pressure matters almost as much as romance. The books are linked by place and community rather than one single plotline, so each one follows a different set of people while still feeling part of the same world. A Heart Once Broken, Until I Love Again, and Always Close to Home all return to the same circle of households, church expectations, and quiet rivalries.

The first book begins with cousins Lydia and Sandra Troyer and their friend Rosemary Beiler, three young women whose friendship gets tested when courtship and money troubles collide. Ezra Wagler becomes the center of attention, but the real tension is not only who will win his heart. It is also about pride, sacrifice, and what happens when family hardship starts shaping romantic choices.

The second book, Until I Love Again, shifts to Susanna Miller during rumspringa. That gives the series a wider emotional range. Susanna is pulled between the Amish future expected of her and a connection to the English world that feels more alive than it should. Old secrets about her family deepen the pressure, so the story becomes as much about identity as it is about love.

In Always Close to Home, the focus moves again, this time to the Mast twins, Laura and Lydia. One sister faces an uncertain future after a terrible accident, while the other waits and wonders whether the man she loves will ever truly choose an Amish life. By this point the series has settled into its main interest, ordinary young people trying to stay faithful while life refuses to stay simple.

What ties these books together is the sense that courtship never happens in private. Parents, church leaders, neighbors, old mistakes, and family finances all press in. That can make the stories feel more dramatic than some softer Amish romances, but it also gives them weight.

If you come to St. Lawrence County looking for cozy scenery alone, you may be surprised. These books have warmth, but they also have jealousy, regret, and hard choices. They are best read as intimate community dramas, where love matters, but so do loyalty, reputation, and the quiet fear of stepping onto the wrong path.