Naomi Troyer Books in Order

Rebecca stays to care for her late sister’s children and gradually falls in love with their father, David. He shares her feelings, but both struggle to reconcile the possibility of a new family with loyalty to the woman they lost.

Sadie plans to marry childhood friend Peter until her father’s new apprentice awakens a connection she cannot dismiss. Torn between a familiar future and feelings for Aaron, she must decide what she wants without betraying the people she loves.

Salome Lantz wants to open a farm stall and hires carpenter Conrad Yoder despite her brother’s reservations. Attraction develops during the work, but concealed history between the two men threatens her confidence in Conrad and the future she imagines with him.

After his father’s death, Benual Lantz must protect his family from losing their farm to a recalled bank loan. Banker Lily Thompson helps him develop a new business plan, while their attraction conflicts with his commitment to his Amish vows.

Shiloh volunteers at a homeless shelter for her congregation’s Christmas season of service and is paired with Isaac, who hurt her best friend. Working together brings attraction and questions about his past, testing whether she can reconsider her judgment of him.

Julia has grown into her inherited role as community matchmaker when farmer Silas arrives under pressure from his father to marry. Finding him a suitable wife proves complicated as duty, tradition and unexpected feelings interfere with the task.

Pregnant widow Grace seeks refuge with estranged Amish in-laws after being left penniless. Jonas offers help, but her difficult family history and uncertain future complicate the affection growing between them as the arrival of her child approaches.

Adopted David hires an investigator to find his birth family and spends Christmas at the inn his mother runs. Growing close to the household and to Joy challenges his sense of belonging as he searches for answers about his origins.

Sadie and Caleb announce their engagement after a secret courtship, only for both families to forbid the marriage without explanation. Investigating their parents’ shared past reveals painful obstacles, forcing them to question whether their love can withstand inherited fear.

Tanner Reynolds enters witness protection after seeing a mob killing and is hidden in an Amish community as Isaac Kauffman. Helping Clara’s family brings them close, but his concealed identity and uncertain departure threaten the trust she is learning to offer.

New farm worker Abram Beiler finds friendship turning into love with his employer’s daughter Hannah. Their private connection becomes harder to protect when her parents propose other suitors, forcing the pair to weigh family loyalty against the future they want together.

Clara Yoder raises her younger siblings and makes carved ornaments after her family’s loss. David Miller returns years after breaking his promise to write, and their rivalry in a Christmas craft competition brings old hurt and unexpected affection back into focus.

Proud Seth cannot make his new draft horse obey, so its seller sends daughter Annie to help train it. Working together challenges Seth’s arrogance and awakens affection, but winning Annie’s trust also means confronting his past and her father’s objections.

Lydia resents her family’s move until rescuing farmer Esau from a barn fire introduces an unexpected romance. Their courtship gives her hope in the new settlement, but a secret threatens their trust and her family’s standing in the community.

Rachel and Noah hide from appointments with a matchmaker and devise a pretend courtship to discourage their parents’ interference. Time together turns their convenient arrangement into something harder to dismiss, testing whether either can admit the feelings emerging beneath it.

Widower Moses returns to his Amish hometown with his daughter twelve years after abandoning Phoebe. The teacher’s old feelings reawaken, but his grief and her memories of rejection make a second chance depend on rebuilding trust between them.

Linda dreams of love arriving unmistakably until a buggy ride with Abram begins challenging her expectations. Letters from a secret admirer introduce a second possibility, leaving her to weigh the man courting her against the writer who seems to understand her.

A woman suffering memory loss finds shelter with widower Daniel Miller and his three children during a blizzard. Growing close through Christmas traditions offers Anna a possible future, but returning memories raise questions about the life she left behind.

Sadie Miller works alongside James Yoder during the Christmas pageant and begins seeing beyond the rumors surrounding his return. His past and other people’s expectations for her future test whether their growing affection can lead to a lasting relationship.

Hannah King preserves her late father’s traditions by organizing the Christmas festival. Returning neighbor Levi Stoltzfus offers help but challenges her methods, and their growing affection becomes vulnerable to a secret that could alter her understanding of the past.

Widow Judith shelters an injured stranger with no memory during a winter blizzard. Caring for him rekindles feelings she thought lost after years of grief, but the return of his past threatens the fragile hope their time together has created.

A storm forces Peter to rescue Annie, a member of the family his own has long treated as enemies. Sheltering together reveals an unexpected connection, but old secrets and inherited loyalties threaten any future they might choose.

Thrift-store owner Abigail guards her heart after personal loss until a stranger’s donation reveals something hidden in the clothing. Caleb’s guilt over his wife’s death draws them into painful secrets, forcing both to reconsider whether they can trust and love again.

Emma’s longstanding affection for Micah conflicts with the feud dividing their families since her brother’s death. A renewed secret connection brings buried history to light, leaving them to decide whether honoring the past must prevent a future together.

Widowed Katie returns to Lancaster County to care for an injured aunt and encounters Eli, the sweetheart she left fifteen years earlier. He is also widowed with two daughters, and renewed feelings challenge both their grief and fears about loving again.

Her brother’s death brings Emma back into contact with his best friend Jacob, reopening feelings she has tried to forget. An arranged marriage stands in the way, forcing Emma to consider whether following her heart would destroy the peace her family expects.

Rachel King expects to obey her father’s plan for an arranged marriage until a chance meeting with newcomer Amos Beiler changes her feelings. As family expectations tighten around her, Rachel must choose between the prescribed future and a relationship she never anticipated.

Born deaf, Anna Lapp longs for someone willing to understand her world. Newcomer Eli King begins building trust through patience and kindness, but their growing affection faces doubts within the community and the challenge of communicating across different experiences.

Penny Stoltzfus protects herself from grief through the routines of her bakery until damage requires urgent repairs before Christmas. Working with reserved contractor Julian Albrecht awakens unexpected feelings, forcing both to confront the losses and regrets they carry.

Emma and Benjamin meet at the altar after their Amish families arrange a marriage neither wants. A private pact helps them endure the situation, but unexpected friendship begins to challenge their resentment and the assumptions they have made about love.

Emily Miller’s mistake in the Yoder store introduces her to Peter, whose kindness contradicts everything her feuding family taught her. A secret courtship develops, leaving the pair to choose between inherited loyalties and the possibility of a future together.

Leah returns to her Amish community for a final Christmas with her dying mother. Trapped by a winter storm with Samuel, the man whose silence once broke her heart, she must decide whether to trust him again.

Lydia Mast suspects neighboring farmer John Lehman when a setback threatens her family’s livelihood. Forced to spend time with the man she considers a rival, she must reconsider old judgments while both confront the pride and misunderstandings keeping them apart.

During Rumspringa, Esther Lapp works at a diner and meets a caring paramedic from the Englisch world. Their friendship prompts questions about faith and belonging as Esther’s approaching return home forces a choice about the future she wants.

Malinda Stoltzfus expects to marry Reuben after the harvest until an Englisch student arrives to study Amish farming. Ben’s dedication and growing closeness with her family challenge her assumptions, leaving Malinda to question the future already planned for her.

Hannah returns home to help her ailing father eight years after Levi ended their engagement. Now a widowed father, Levi reenters her life through his daughter’s quilting lessons, bringing old feelings and unanswered questions about their broken relationship back to the surface.

Miriam Graber has devoted herself to caring for her aging parents, but widowed carpenter Daniel Yutzi offers an unexpected future. When her parents refuse his marriage proposal, she must weigh family obedience against the possibility of love and a home of her own.

A mysterious letter draws corporate worker Cindy Davidson from New Jersey to an inherited Amish farm. There she meets Willis Beiler, the man protecting its legacy, and must confront family secrets and questions of belonging as affection grows between them.

Beiler twins Hazel and Holly face different tests of love as a spring festival approaches. Hazel’s work with an irritating neighbor stirs unexpected feelings, while a misunderstanding threatens Holly’s relationship, leaving both sisters searching for courage and trust.

A storm devastates widow Mary Stoltzfus’s farm while she struggles to raise three children. Carpenter John Beiler helps rebuild the property, but growing trust raises a harder question for Mary: whether she can risk opening her heart after loss.

Facing a failed harvest and dwindling savings, Alice asks experienced farmer Levi Beiler to teach her how to save her parents’ land. Their work creates an unexpected bond, though community gossip and concerns about independence make both hesitate to pursue it.

A storm destroys the bridge out of Leah Kauffman’s valley and forces two feuding families to cooperate. Her bond with Caleb Beiler grows during repairs, but his discovery about the feud’s origins threatens to reopen old wounds or destroy her trust.

Midwife Emma Graber has guarded her heart since a betrayal, until widower Noah Zook brings his fragile infant daughter into her care. A growing bond offers renewed hope, but the return of her past forces Emma to reconsider whom she can trust.

After losing his parents, Abram King puts the family farm and his young brothers ahead of romance. Nanny Rachel Maas brings warmth into their grieving home, but the feelings they develop complicate his sense of duty and her place in the household.