Magic in Chancellor Books in Order
Part ofMelanie Karsak Books in OrderBrowse Magic in Chancellor by Melanie Karsak in order, with cozy fantasy summaries, small-town series background, and easy where-to-start help.
Last updated: July 8, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Magic in Chancellor books in publication order
5 books
The Cupcake Witch
by Melanie Karsak
2018
After her mother's death, Julie inherits a magical chance to build the bakery she really wants. In Chancellor, spells, sweets, and a stubborn local heir turn a fresh start into an unexpected romance.
The Fairy Godfather
by Melanie Karsak
2018
Another Chancellor romance mixes magic and matchmaking as a fairy-tale twist upends one couple's plans. In a town where happily ever after is real, love arrives in the most inconvenient way.
The Glass Mermaid
by Melanie Karsak
2018
Kate, the last mermaid, spends her fading days on the shore collecting beach glass and waiting for her magic to end. Then she meets Cooper, and love begins to feel possible just when time is running out.
The Book Witch
by Melanie Karsak
2022
Books and magic make a potent combination in Chancellor, especially when the past starts speaking up. This cozy fantasy entry leans into charm, community, and spellwork wrapped around love.
The Vintage Medium
by Melanie Karsak
2022
Back in Chancellor, a new heroine finds ghosts, feelings, and old mysteries refusing to stay buried. It blends small-town magic with a gentle romance and a touch of the uncanny.
Magic in Chancellor books in chronological order

The Glass Mermaid
by Melanie Karsak
2018Magic in Chancellor, Book 1
The Cupcake Witch
by Melanie Karsak
2018Magic in Chancellor, Book 2
The Fairy Godfather
by Melanie Karsak
2018Magic in Chancellor, Book 3
The Vintage Medium
by Melanie Karsak
2022Magic in Chancellor, Book 4
The Book Witch
by Melanie Karsak
2022Magic in Chancellor, Book 5
Series background & context
Magic in Chancellor is the side of Melanie Karsak that reaches for comfort, charm, and happily ever after, without giving up magic altogether. The series is set in the small town of Chancellor, a place where fairy-tale logic feels close to the surface and love stories have a habit of finding the people who need them most.
The town is the real anchor. Chancellor feels lived in, local, and a little enchanted. Shops matter. Old houses matter. Neighbors notice things. The setting has that small-town fantasy rhythm where every storefront seems to hold a secret and every newcomer might stumble into a new life by accident. That gives the books a warm, inviting feel.
The stories themselves are lighter than Karsak's historical sagas. The Glass Mermaid opens the series with a bittersweet romance touched by loss and magic on the shore of Lake Erie. The Cupcake Witch leans into baking, inheritance, and the pleasure of building a dream from scratch. Later books keep the same mood, giving new couples, new magical problems, and new emotional fresh starts inside the same world.
That stand-alone quality is part of the appeal. You can read the books in order and enjoy the growing sense of place, or dip in when a particular premise catches your eye. What ties them together is tone rather than one giant plot. These are stories about healing, choosing a truer life, and finding romance in a place where the ordinary is always one step away from enchantment.
If you like cozy fantasy romance, this series is a good fit. Expect mermaids, witches, mediums, and other fairy-tale touches, but not heavy epic stakes. The tension is personal, emotional, and local. A bakery, a bookshop, a cottage, a ghost, or an inherited secret can matter just as much here as a battlefield matters in Karsak's larger historical fantasy. That smaller scale is the point.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.















Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts