Lost Sisters Of Pleasant Valley Books in Order

The Lost Sisters of Pleasant Valley grows directly out of the Pleasant Valley books, but it has its own clear emotional hook. These novels follow sisters who were separated when they were young and discover one another years later inside the same Amish world.

That reunion changes everything.

In Lydia's Hope, the first shock is simple and enormous: the family story Lydia thought she knew is not the whole story. By Susanna's Dream, the idea expands into a fuller picture of what reunion really costs. Finding lost family is comforting, but it also means reopening grief, rethinking identity, and making room for relationships that should have existed all along.

Because the series is tied to Pleasant Valley, readers still get the rural Pennsylvania setting, the familiar Amish rhythms, and the same careful attention to work, courtship, and community. But the emotional engine is more directly about belonging. These books ask what it means to build sisterhood after years of separation, and whether new love can grow while old losses are still fresh.

If you liked Pleasant Valley and wanted more from that world, this is the natural next step. The books work best in order, and they are especially good for readers who like family revelations as much as romance.