Elizabeth J Duncan Books in Order
Explore Elizabeth J Duncan books in order, with quick summaries, series guides for Penny Brannigan and Shakespeare in the Catskills, and where to start.
Last updated: June 8, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Publication Order
14 books
The Cold Light of Mourning
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2009
In Llanelen, an unpopular bride vanishes on her wedding day and later turns up dead. Penny Brannigan was among the last to see Meg alive, and her questions lead from wedding gossip to a darker secret that could shake the whole town.
A Brush with Death
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2010
After inheriting a cottage from a beloved friend, Penny discovers letters and a painting that point to the long-ago death of a young Liverpool artist. Her search leads from North Wales to the art world, where buried relationships and missing works still matter.
A Killer's Christmas in Wales
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2011
As Penny and Victoria race to open their new spa before Christmas, a charming American disappears with a widow's money and then turns up dead. Penny investigates to clear her friend, while a string of thefts suggests the murder reaches further than anyone thinks.
A Small Hill to Die On
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2012
Llanelen starts buzzing when a wealthy Vietnamese family moves into the big house on the hill. After Penny finds the teenage daughter buried in the countryside, she follows the case into local suspicion, old violence, and danger close to home.
Never Laugh As a Hearse Goes By
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2013
Penny attends a clerical conference at Gladstone's Library with DCI Gareth Davies, expecting talks and quiet surroundings, not murder. When the bishop's secretary dies and another body follows, Penny helps trace blackmail, deception, and secrets hidden in shorthand notes.
Slated for Death
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2015
When Glenda Roberts is found dead at the bottom of a former slate mine, Penny gets pulled in after her own hand cream turns up among counterfeit goods. The police see an easy suspect, but Penny senses a deeper family secret behind the killing.
Untimely Death
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2015
During a Catskills production of Romeo and Juliet, leading lady Lauren Richmond is poisoned and then stabbed. Costume designer Charlotte Fairfax knows the company from the inside, and her curiosity makes her the perfect person to untangle rivalries, gossip, and motive.
Ill Met by Murder
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2016
A moonlight performance of A Midsummer Night's Dream at Paula Van Dusen's estate is meant to celebrate a wedding, until a family friend is murdered with a stolen prop. Charlotte Fairfax juggles costumes, money troubles, and long-buried secrets to find the killer.
Murder on the Hour
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2016
Llanelen is buzzing over a visiting antiques television show when a quiet local woman turns up dead and her handmade quilt vanishes. Penny soon learns that a document hidden in an old clock may unlock both a family secret and the murder.
Much Ado About Murder
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2017
Charlotte Fairfax is busy costuming Much Ado About Nothing when a high-flying British director arrives and alienates nearly everyone around him. After his supposed suicide looks wrong, Charlotte starts pulling apart a cast full of grudges, ambition, and hidden alliances.
Murder Is for Keeps
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2017
While sketching Gwrych Castle, Penny gets drawn into a restoration project that turns deadly when a volunteer is found murdered in an outbuilding. The case pulls her and retired detective Gareth Davies into the estate's history and an older unsolved crime.
The Marmalade Murders
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2018
At Llanelen's agricultural show, missing entries and a missing guild member seem like minor trouble until a body is found under the baked goods table. Penny suspects the obvious suspect is being framed and digs into a tangle of rivalries and secrets.
Remembering the Dead
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2019
Penny organizes a formal dinner marking the end of World War One, only to find a historic Welsh chair stolen and a waiter murdered. The two mysteries appear linked, sending her into a race through old thefts, family ties, and buried grudges.
On Deadly Tides
by Elizabeth J Duncan
2020
On an Anglesey painting holiday, Penny Brannigan finds a New Zealand journalist dead on a secluded beach. What looks like a fall soon points to murder and an older disappearance, while Penny faces unexpected changes in her own life.
Where should I start?
If you want classic Welsh village mysteries: The Cold Light of Mourning → A Brush with Death → A Killer's Christmas in Wales
If you like theater and backstage drama: Untimely Death → Ill Met by Murder → Much Ado About Murder
If you want Penny at her most settled and confident: Murder on the Hour → The Marmalade Murders → On Deadly Tides
If you only want one quick sample: The Cold Light of Mourning for North Wales, or Untimely Death for the Catskills.
Author bio
Elizabeth J Duncan is a Canadian mystery writer whose books love a strong sense of place. North Wales, the Catskills, village fairs, old hotels, libraries, and country houses all matter in her work. Before she turned to novels, she studied English at Carleton University in Ottawa and spent years in journalism, working as a writer and editor for newspapers including the Ottawa Citizen and the Hamilton Spectator.
She came to fiction later than some writers, and that late start seems to have suited her.
Duncan also lived and worked in London, England, for five years as a freelance writer and broadcaster. Later, she worked in public relations and taught at Humber. That mix of jobs helps explain why her mysteries feel so grounded in ordinary working life, with close attention to how people talk, what they notice, and what a community remembers.
Her first novel, The Cold Light of Mourning, introduced readers to Penny Brannigan, a Canadian expatriate in North Wales who keeps finding trouble in the most beautiful places. The manuscript won the William F. Deeck-Malice Domestic Grant for Unpublished Writers, and the published book went on to win the St. Martin's/Malice Domestic Award for best first traditional mystery. It was also nominated for both the Agatha Award and Canada's Arthur Ellis Award for best first novel.
Not a bad way to begin.
She stayed with Penny for a long run. Books such as A Brush with Death, A Small Hill to Die On, Murder on the Hour, and On Deadly Tides show what readers keep coming back for: a smart, steady central sleuth, a Welsh setting full of history and weather and local habit, and mysteries that grow out of family tensions, village gossip, old secrets, and the odd chance discovery. Later Penny books also picked up Bony Blithe awards, which fits the series well because these are traditional mysteries with warmth, humor, and very little fuss.
Duncan's second series shifts the stage but keeps the appeal. In Untimely Death, Ill Met by Murder, and Much Ado About Murder, the sleuth is Charlotte Fairfax, a costume designer with the Catskills Shakespeare Theater Company. Those books lean into backstage politics, artistic egos, rehearsal chaos, and the fun of watching theater people try to keep a show running while someone has just been murdered.
Across both series, Duncan tends to write about capable women who are observant, curious, and a bit more stubborn than is probably wise. She likes close communities, whether that means a Welsh market town or a summer theater crowd, and she has a knack for making the setting feel like part of the case. Readers who enjoy cozy and traditional mysteries usually come for the puzzle, then stay for the atmosphere.
These are comfort reads, but never empty ones.
Duncan lives in Toronto and spends several months each year in North Wales. That yearly return to Wales is easy to see on the page. Her Welsh books, in particular, feel written by someone who notices the landscape, the history underfoot, and the small social details that make a place feel lived in.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.
































Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts