Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

DCI James Craig Books in Order

Part ofJohn Carson Books in Order

This page collects the DCI James Craig novels by John Carson in order, with quick plot summaries, series background and where to start with these Fife based Scottish police mysteries.

Last updated: December 26, 2025

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Publication Order

Sort:

8 books

1

When Devils Dance With Saints

by John Carson

2025

After literary agent Sarah Matthews is murdered in her St Andrews office, DCI James Craig discovers pages from an unpublished manuscript describing her death in exact detail. When further chapters arrive predicting more killings in the publishing world, he must unmask a killer who is using fiction as a script and seems determined to write Craig into the final act.

2

Thin Blue Lies

by John Carson

2025

A series of brutal attacks on serving and former detectives pulls James Craig into a joint investigation with DCI Harry McNeil. As ex members of an elite police unit are picked off with chilling precision, the two teams uncover a buried scandal inside the force and realise that all of them may be on the killer’s list.

3

Evil Lives Here

by John Carson

2025

In a remote hotel far from help, staff discover a man murdered in a room and a dead woman posed in an armchair watching him, the scene partially burned. Craig’s investigation reveals a killer who carefully stages victims before dousing the flames, leaving him chasing a meticulous planner whose motives are rooted in trauma that refuses to stay buried.

4

Always The Quiet Ones

by John Carson

2025

When teenager Heather Ross disappears in rural Fife, whispers about the Shadow Watchers, eerie figures from local folklore, resurface in the hills. As Craig and his team follow leads involving land deals, stolen artefacts and buried grudges, the disappearances turn lethal and the line between old legend and modern violence grows dangerously thin.

5

Whispers of Guilt

by John Carson

2024

Forensic pathologist Annie Keller visits her uncle, retired judge William Hawthorne, who in a moment of clarity claims to know the identity of a killer. When a new body turns up matching his hazy description, DCI James Craig must decide how seriously to take the words of a man with dementia while powerful figures work to keep old decisions hidden.

6

One of the Broken

by John Carson

2024

A well liked man is found bludgeoned to death in his own home, a jigsaw piece clenched in his hand. As DCI James Craig and his new team dig into the victim’s carefully managed life, they uncover a darker alter ego and realise the killer may be working through a list of targets connected to old sins.

7

Ice Into Ashes

by John Carson

2024

Returning to Fife for his wife’s uncle’s funeral, London detective James Craig is uneasy with the tidy explanation that the old man simply fell downstairs. When small details refuse to add up, Craig joins the inquiry and uncovers links to a long ago serial case from his probationer days, forcing him to face a killer he thought he had left in the past.

8

Dead On Arrival

by John Carson

2024

At the Burntisland carnival, two teenage girls enjoy the rides, unaware one of them is being stalked. The next morning, her body is discovered in a cemetery with a symbol carved into her forehead that Craig recognises from an unsolved case. When more victims appear echoing other investigations from his past, he realises someone is recreating the murders he never quite closed.

Series background & context

DCI James Craig brings a fresh angle to John Carson’s Scottish crime world. He is not a lifelong Police Scotland officer, but a London detective who comes north for a family funeral and ends up staying.

The series opens in Ice Into Ashes with Craig returning to Fife after the sudden death of his wife’s uncle. Officially, the old man fell down the stairs. Unofficially, something about the scene does not sit right with Craig, whose instincts have been sharpened by years in the Met. When he looks closer, he uncovers links to an uncaught serial killer from his early career, a man known as Starman who almost ended his life.

That blend of personal history and new violence runs through all the books. Craig accepts a post running a Major Investigation Team and is soon joined by Scottish colleagues who have their own baggage and loyalties. His partnership with DS Isla McGregor and, later, with other sergeants becomes one of the anchors of the series.

The cases themselves often loop back to earlier failures or long buried decisions. In One of the Broken, a well liked man is found murdered with a jigsaw piece in his hand, hinting at a far darker side to his life and suggesting there may be more victims in danger. Dead On Arrival centres on carnival fun that turns sour when a teenage girl is killed and her body marked with symbols that echo several of Craig’s old unsolved cases.

The books also have a strong sense of place. Whispers of Guilt lingers in nursing homes and courtrooms as Craig and forensic pathologist Annie Keller pick apart a retired judge’s confused memories of a killer he claims to recognise. Evil Lives Here isolates the team in a remote hotel where bodies are left posed and partially burned, each scene hinting at a plan that has been in motion for decades.

Later entry Always The Quiet Ones ventures into rural folklore, with missing teenagers, Shadow Watchers in the hills, and land deals that hide more than financial stakes. Upcoming titles like Thin Blue Lies and When Devils Dance With Saints promise even deeper ties between Craig’s investigations, the publishing world, and secrets that reach into the police themselves.

Craig’s stories are for readers who like interconnected cases, a detective carrying scars from earlier work, and a setting that moves between coastal towns, universities, and the shadow of old crimes. There is plenty of procedural grit, but also an emotional throughline in his relationships with colleagues and with Annie, which develop alongside the investigations.

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

Comments

Did we miss something? Have feedback?

Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts

We only use your email to notify you about replies.

All comments are moderated.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.

All 8 DCI James Craig Books in Order (Complete List 2026)