AJ McCarthy Books in Order
Explore AJ McCarthy books in order, with brief summaries, where-to-start advice, and a clear guide to her Canadian mystery and suspense stories.
Last updated: July 15, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
AJ McCarthy books in publication order
7 books
Betrayal
by AJ McCarthy
2015
An early mystery-suspense novel from A.J. McCarthy, Betrayal explores concealed motives, danger, and the high cost of placing trust in the wrong person.
Sins of the Fathers
by AJ McCarthy
2017
Montreal pub owner Charlie receives anonymous letters that disturbingly point toward a past she would rather leave buried. With police help unavailable, she hires private investigator Simm, and their search reaches from Montreal's underworld to organized crime in Dublin.
Cold Betrayal
by AJ McCarthy
2018
Victoria Anderson drives from Florida to Quebec in search of Danny Wilcox, a man she refuses to abandon. Stranded in winter and pursued by killers, Tori must decide whom she can trust while the criminal world around Danny closes in.
Legacy of Fear
by AJ McCarthy
2019
Emily Burton's quiet life in a small Vancouver Island town is destroyed by a brutal attack and a murder. As threats continue, she and her mysterious neighbor uncover a similar crime from sixty years earlier, and race to find its connection to the present.
By the Book
by AJ McCarthy
2020
A page from a paperback is left at an Ottawa murder scene, then detectives Josh Riddell and Clint Weller realize a serial killer is following the novel's plot. With potential victims mounting, they must solve the story before its final chapter is written.
Faux Friends
by AJ McCarthy
2021
After a failed case sends her to desk duty, Quebec police officer Chantal Pouliot sees a cybercrime assignment as her way back undercover. But when the case turns deadly, she and Jeff Lafond face organized crime and someone who knows Chantal's past.
The Other Side
by AJ McCarthy
2022
Charlie and her former private-investigator husband, Simm, take a missing-person case in Quebec's Gatineau region. What begins as a chance to investigate old drownings leads them into small-town secrets, suspicious deaths, and danger tied to Simm's family.
Where to start with AJ McCarthy
For the Charlie and Simm mysteries: Sins of the Fathers → The Other Side.
For a wintry crime thriller: Cold Betrayal.
For a serial-killer investigation: By the Book.
For a suspense story with a past connection: Legacy of Fear.
For a police thriller: Faux Friends.
Standalone AJ McCarthy books
Author bio
A.J. McCarthy was born in Quebec City and grew up in Quebec. She later built a career in finance and accounting, staying in the province while raising two daughters with her husband. That everyday work life sits a long way from murder investigations and people on the run, which may be part of why her fiction likes to upset orderly plans.
Mystery was there early. McCarthy grew up reading Agatha Christie, Sidney Sheldon, and other writers of mystery and suspense. Those books gave her a lasting taste for hidden motives, troubling secrets, and the uneasy feeling that someone in the room isn't telling the whole truth.
Writing became a new challenge alongside her professional life. Her early novel Betrayal was followed by Sins of the Fathers, published in 2017, and she continued to build a body of standalone thrillers as well as the Charlie and Simm mysteries.
She has a practical eye for what happens when safety slips.
In Sins of the Fathers, Montreal pub owner Charlene, known as Charlie, receives anonymous letters that pull her into a dangerous investigation. The book also introduces Simm, the private investigator who helps her. Their shared story continues in The Other Side, where the couple takes on a missing-person case in Quebec's Gatineau region. The series makes room for crime, family history, and the messy business of learning whom to trust.
Montreal matters in these books.
McCarthy's standalones travel through other Canadian settings while keeping the pressure close to the characters. Cold Betrayal follows Victoria Anderson as her search for a man takes her from Florida into a harsh Quebec winter and the orbit of organized crime. In Legacy of Fear, Emily Burton's peaceful life on Vancouver Island is shattered by an attack and a murder with possible roots in the past. By the Book moves to Ottawa, where detectives hunt a killer using a novel as a blueprint.
Faux Friends centers on Quebec police officer Chantal Pouliot, who hopes a cybercrime assignment will help restore her career after a case goes wrong. Instead, she finds murder, organized crime, and a threat tied to her own past. Across these stories, McCarthy returns to people who are pushed into danger before they have all the facts.
Her work has brought recognition, including a 2019 American Fiction Award for Cold Betrayal. She is also associated with Crime Writers of Canada, Sisters in Crime, and International Thriller Writers, groups that fit naturally with a writer drawn to crime and suspense.
When she isn't writing, McCarthy has said she is likely reading. It makes sense. Her books are built for readers who enjoy following clues, questioning loyalties, and watching ordinary lives take a sharp, dangerous turn.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

























Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts