Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

17 Best Jodi Picoult Books

The best Jodi Picoult books, ranked by how many expert sources recommend each one, with notes for readers choosing family drama, legal fiction or mystery.

Our take

Jodi Picoult’s novels put difficult moral questions inside intimate relationships. Parents, children, lawyers and witnesses often see the same crisis differently, and the reader has to decide which claims deserve sympathy. Her books suit people who enjoy discussing choices after finishing a novel, particularly when love and duty point in different directions. Expect intense feelings, contested assumptions and endings that can change your interpretation of what came before.

My Sister’s Keeper is a clear introduction to her combination of family conflict and medical ethics. Plain Truth gives more space to a legal case and a community with different expectations, while Nineteen Minutes examines the aftermath of a school shooting. The Storyteller connects present-day choices to Holocaust history. For something beyond conventional courtroom drama, Leaving Time and Second Glance include supernatural elements, and Wish You Were Here uses pandemic disruption to question an apparently settled future. Begin with the subject you most want to discuss, since these stories differ considerably in emotional weight.

17 books · 9 sources · Last updated

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Reading Jodi Picoult in order? See all Jodi Picoult books in order

How to choose from this list

Skip to the full ranking

If you want a first Picoult novel: My Sister's Keeper
If you want a courtroom drama: Plain Truth → Small Great Things
If you want medical and family ethics: Handle with Care
If you want history and moral responsibility: The Storyteller
If you want supernatural mystery: Second Glance → Leaving Time
If you want a life changed by unexpected events: Wish You Were Here

The 17 books, ranked

Ranked by how many expert sources name each book. Ties go to the book more people recommend.

1

My Sister's Keeper

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2004

For newcomers who want family loyalty tested by a difficult question about bodily autonomy. Its competing perspectives create substantial discussion material, though the emotional intensity and late turns can feel deliberately overwhelming.

What it's about

Anna was conceived to be a marrow donor for her leukemia-stricken sister, Kate. At thirteen, she sues her parents for medical emancipation to stop the procedures. The lawsuit exposes deep family fractures and asks who owns a child's body.

2

The Storyteller

by Jodi Picoult2013

For readers who want historical trauma connected to present-day questions about forgiveness. Its layered accounts give moral responsibility considerable weight, though the Holocaust material and shifting narrative strands require emotional stamina and close attention.

What it's about

Sage Singer befriends a beloved old man in her grief support group, only to learn he was a Nazi SS officer. He asks her to help him die, forcing Sage to confront her own grandmother's Holocaust survival story and the limits of forgiveness.

3

Nineteen Minutes

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2007

For readers willing to examine a community’s responsibilities after catastrophic violence. Its many viewpoints connect private pain with public judgment, though the school shooting and sustained distress make it a demanding choice for leisure reading.

What it's about

After years of bullying, a student opens fire at his high school, changing the town of Sterling forever. The novel explores the shooting from multiple perspectives—the shooter, the victims, and the judge whose own daughter is a witness.

4

Plain Truth

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2000

For readers who enjoy courtroom fiction complicated by different ideas of community and belonging. The contrast between an attorney’s assumptions and Amish life gives the case texture, though the legal framework becomes familiar if you know Picoult well.

What it's about

A dead infant is found in an Amish barn, and an eighteen-year-old Amish girl denies she was ever pregnant. A high-profile defense attorney, hiding in the community to escape her own life, agrees to defend her in a clash of cultures and justice.

5

Small Great Things

Ruth Jefferson, Book 2

by Picoult Jodi & Jodi Picoult2016

For book clubs interested in racism, institutional authority and the limits of good intentions. Its conflicting perspectives make assumptions visible, though the direct moral framing can feel more like an argument than subtle characterization.

What it's about

Ruth Jefferson, an experienced Black nurse, is ordered not to touch the baby of a white supremacist couple. When the baby goes into cardiac arrest and she hesitates, she is charged with murder, triggering a trial about race and privilege.

6

Leaving Time

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2014

For readers open to a mystery that connects human grief with elephant behavior. Its unusual combination of perspectives distinguishes it from the courtroom novels, though the supernatural elements will not suit readers expecting a conventional investigation.

What it's about

Jenna Metcalf has never stopped looking for her mother, an elephant researcher who vanished after a tragic accident. She teams up with a disgraced psychic and a jaded detective to uncover the truth, which is far stranger than she imagined.

7

The Pact

A Love Story

by Jodi Picoult1998

For readers drawn to the gap between parents’ certainty and their children’s private lives. Its focus on two intertwined families makes the questions intimate, though suicide and the heavy emotional pressure leave little relief.

What it's about

Two teenagers, inseparable since birth, are found shot in a swimming pool; one is dead, the other holds the gun. The surviving boy claims it was a suicide pact, but the investigation unravels a lifetime of secrets between their two families.

8

Change of Heart

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2008

For readers interested in redemption, belief and the moral tensions surrounding punishment. Its unusual ethical problem gives a book club several angles to debate, though the religious questions and dramatic coincidences may overwhelm the human-scale story.

What it's about

A death row inmate offers to donate his heart to the sister of the victim he was convicted of killing. The story questions the nature of redemption, the death penalty, and whether a miracle can come from a murderer.

9

Handle with Care

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2009

For readers interested in the tension between parental advocacy, friendship and a child’s sense of worth. Its family perspectives complicate a medical lawsuit, though the accumulating suffering and legal conflict can feel relentless.

What it's about

A family struggles to pay for the medical care of their daughter, who has a severe brittle-bone disease. The mother makes a controversial decision to sue her obstetrician—her best friend—for wrongful birth, arguing she should have had the option to abort.

10

House Rules

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2010

For readers interested in how communication differences can shape an investigation and strain family relationships. Its courtroom premise invites questions about assumptions, though the characterization represents one fictional experience rather than a guide to autism.

What it's about

Jacob Hunt, a teenager with Asperger's syndrome and an obsession with forensic science, is accused of murdering his tutor. His behaviors, often misread by police as guilt, force his mother to fight a legal system that doesn't understand him.

11

Salem Falls

by Jodi Picoult2001

For readers who enjoy small-town suspicion, reputation and the difficulty of starting again. Its attention to collective judgment makes the legal drama compelling, though sexual-assault allegations and the overt echoes of a witch hunt require care.

What it's about

A teacher with a past conviction for sexual assault moves to a small town for a fresh start. He finds love and a simple life until a group of teenage girls accuses him of a crime, forcing the town to decide if history is repeating itself.

12

Second Glance

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2003

For readers who want Picoult’s family concerns in a ghost story with romance and historical layers. Its supernatural approach widens the possibilities, though the many connections require more acceptance of coincidence than the realistic legal novels.

What it's about

In a town plagued by inexplicable events, a ghost hunter is hired to prove a property isn't haunted so a developer can build a mall. Instead, he uncovers a murder mystery from the 1930s involving eugenics and a love story that refuses to die.

13

Keeping Faith

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult1999

For readers who want family drama complicated by faith and uncertainty. Its refusal to make belief a purely private matter gives the custody conflict depth, though apparent miracles ask for more openness than a strictly realistic legal novel.

What it's about

After a messy divorce, a young girl begins talking to an invisible friend who might be God. When she starts performing apparent miracles, her mother must fight a custody battle against a father who uses the religious controversy to claim she is unfit.

14

Perfect Match

by Jodi Picoult2002

For readers interested in the boundary between protecting a child and seeking personal justice. Its prosecutor’s perspective makes that tension especially sharp, though child abuse and revenge keep the story emotionally difficult throughout.

What it's about

A district attorney who has spent her career putting criminals behind bars takes the law into her own hands when her five-year-old son is abused. She finds herself on the other side of the courtroom, forced to defend an indefensible act.

15

The Book of Two Ways

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2020

For readers who enjoy questions about alternative lives, mortality and unfinished love. Its Egyptology material gives the reflection a distinctive setting, though the technical detail and shifting structure interrupt the pace of the relationship story.

What it's about

After surviving a plane crash, a death doula finds herself thinking not of her husband, but of an old flame from her Egyptology days. She decides to pursue the path not taken, leading to a journey across the globe and into the past.

16

The Tenth Circle

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2006

For readers interested in a father’s anger and the limits of understanding a teenager. The integration of comic art gives the family drama a distinctive form, though the symbolism and multiple strands can feel crowded.

What it's about

When a comic book artist's teenage daughter claims she was raped, the family fractures. The father, who draws superheroes for a living, struggles with his own desire for vengeance, blurring the line between his ink-and-paper justice and reality.

17

Wish You Were Here

A Novel

by Jodi Picoult2021

For readers interested in how a disrupted future can change someone’s sense of identity. Its isolation and uncertainty make the choices personal, though the pandemic setting and major narrative turns may be difficult for readers seeking straightforward realism.

What it's about

Diana O'Toole is stranded in the Galápagos Islands when the COVID-19 pandemic shuts down the world. Cut off from her life in New York, she re-evaluates her entire future, only to discover that her isolation is not what it seems.

Sources

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shape MRB and its growth.

Comments

Spotted a missing book, a wrong order or a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix this page.

We're a reading guide, not the author or publisher, so we can't send books or pass on messages.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.