Witches of Holiday Hills Cozy Mystery Books in Order

After her mother dies, mystery writer Abby Odell discovers she is a witch and that Holiday Hills hides a supernatural community. When newly discovered relatives are murdered, she and her talking-cat familiar must investigate before the killer reaches her.

Abby Odell’s fictional mysteries begin happening in real life, placing her in the dangers she invented for her heroine. With help from her talking-cat familiar, the witch and ghostwriter must discover who cast the spell before her own plot kills her.

Unexplained magical events threaten to expose Holiday Hills’ supernatural residents to their human neighbors. Abby Odell must discover who is causing the disturbances before fear turns the town against its witches and destroys the community she has come to love.

The murder of an unpopular witch unsettles Holiday Hills, where breaking magical rules could put everyone at risk. Abby Odell and her familiar help investigate, seeking the motive and culprit before the danger spreads beyond its first victim.

Abby Odell hopes to continue her late mother’s festival tradition, but a volunteer’s murder threatens the event and its library fundraiser. With the police chief away, she and her talking cat investigate while an unhelpful deputy complicates their efforts.

Holiday Hills is preparing for Christmas when Santa’s messengers reveal that his list has been stolen and hidden in town. Abby Odell and her cat familiar Cooper must recover it before the missing list prevents the holiday from happening.

A magical potion disappears while usually grumpy supernatural residents become strangely cheerful. Asked to recover the missing elixir, Abby Odell and her cat Cooper follow clues through Holiday Hills before its unusual effects create a larger problem.

A visiting chef is murdered during Holiday Hills’ culinary competition, and Abby Odell investigates when her friend Bessie becomes involved. Sabotage, cryptic threats, and another friend’s magical crisis complicate her search for the killer.

A town-wide hex leaves Holiday Hills’ witches and other magical residents behaving unpredictably. When one of Abby Odell’s suspects turns up dead, she and her talking cat must solve both the murder and the spreading magical disorder.

A reporter discovers Holiday Hills’ magical secret and is soon found dead in the lake. Abby Odell believes the accused shapeshifter is innocent, but proving it means navigating a frightened community desperate to protect its hidden world.

The enchanted music sheets for Bessie’s annual Christmas carol night disappear, threatening a treasured Holiday Hills tradition. Abby, her cat Cooper, and their friends follow the clues to recover the songs before the celebration falls silent.

Holiday Hills’ psychic predicts his own death, and Abby’s cat Cooper foresees the same fate. When the prediction comes true and Stella becomes the prime suspect, Abby must clear her friend before another warning turns into reality.

A notorious witch is murdered, leaving a note that points toward someone known only as Miss Goody Witch Shoes. A second death convinces Abby Odell that a serial killer is stalking Holiday Hills’ magical community.

When Bessie’s ancestral wand disappears, she threatens to sell the beloved Enchanted Bookstore and Café. Abby and her talking cat investigate, but a suspect’s murder transforms the search into a race to protect both their friend and themselves.

A discredited health inspector is found dead after angering Holiday Hills’ business owners. Abby investigates the attempt to frame a local baker, questioning whether she was merely a convenient suspect or the killer’s true intended target.

Abby Odell’s former boyfriend disappears, and she suspects someone in Holiday Hills knows what happened. With her talking cat’s help, she investigates a mystery that threatens to entangle her romantic life with dangerous magical secrets.

A young witch dies while serving drinks at the Enchanted Bookstore and Café, shattering Abby’s familiar refuge. Investigating with her friends and familiars, she uncovers troubling connections involving love potions, old grievances, and hidden motives.

When a rival bookseller accuses Bessie of sabotage, Holiday Hills fills with rumors. An explosion and the man’s subsequent death make matters worse, leaving Abby and her companions determined to clear Bessie and identify the culprit.

Abby discovers a controversial spell-breaker murdered beside a cryptic note. With dark magic spreading through Holiday Hills, she and her friends must determine who wanted the witch dead before the danger reaches someone else.

At Holiday Hills’ Magical Market, Abby’s talking cat discovers an unpopular resident turned to stone. With numerous people holding grudges, Abby follows magical clues alongside her police-chief boyfriend to identify the culprit before another attack.

Malicious spells disrupt Christmas throughout Holiday Hills, and suspicion falls on a recent arrival. When a close friend suffers a dangerous hex, Abby joins an unusual magical ally to uncover who is sabotaging the town’s celebrations.

The death of a man responsible for maintaining Holiday Hills’ pact between humans and magical residents threatens the whole community. Abby investigates poisoned books, unstable alliances, and dark magic before the agreement unravels completely.

A powerful spell book disappears from the Enchanted Bookstore and Café, putting Holiday Hills at risk. Abby and her outspoken cat Cooper work with an unexpectedly helpful detective to find the thief before the stolen magic is misused.

An obsessive fan arrives in Holiday Hills claiming to know Abby is a real witch and exposing other residents’ secrets. When the visitor is murdered, Abby must untangle the case while protecting her community from discovery.

The murder of a popular vampire leaves his cousin Bianca devastated and Holiday Hills full of questions. Abby, Stella, and their familiars investigate the apparently well-liked victim’s past while trying to support their grieving friend.

A local witch dies shortly after sharing a potentially transformative secret with Abby. Suspecting murder, Abby and Cooper pursue answers, only to discover that more members of Holiday Hills’ magical community wanted the victim silenced.

A witch’s familiar attacks its owner and disappears, then behaves as though possessed when Abby finds it. After the witch turns up dead, Abby must determine whether the creature is a victim, a suspect, or something more dangerous.

Cooper’s curiosity traps Abby inside a magical snow globe during Christmas preparations. Enjoying his temporary freedom, the talking cat delays admitting what happened, until the risk of the globe being given away makes rescue urgent.

When a visiting witch reports her familiar missing, Cooper takes charge of the investigation before Abby can begin. Following suspicious spellwork through Holiday Hills, the talking cat discovers a scheme exploiting magical companions for someone else’s gain.

A hex scrambles the children’s wishes at Holiday Hills’ enchanted Christmas listening post. With the faulty magic spreading and North Pole investigators arriving, Abby must catch the culprit before Christmas Eve ends and Santa’s visit becomes impossible.

Stolen ceremonial hats and a gnome’s murder threaten to start a conflict with Holiday Hills’ trolls. Abby tries to mediate and investigate, but the gnomes refuse to speak to witches while accusing their neighbors without evidence.

A break-in at Holiday Hills’ hex registry unleashes unstable magic across town. Abby and Cooper follow the trail of stolen spells while emotions spiral and authorities demand answers before the damage becomes permanent.

A living, outspoken painting disappears from a Holiday Hills gallery without signs of a struggle. Cooper investigates suspicious collectors, counterfeit spells, and a helpful appraiser, questioning whether the apparent theft hides something more carefully arranged.

An enchanted newspaper begins publishing Holiday Hills’ secrets whenever residents repeat gossip. Accused of creating the chaos, Abby and Cooper must uncover who controls the publication before exposed scandals and growing anger tear their community apart.