The Kincaids Books in Order
Part ofStacy Reid Books in OrderExplore The Kincaids western historical romances by Stacy Reid in order, with plot summaries, family background, and tips on where to begin this frontier love story cycle.
Last updated: December 23, 2025
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Publication Order
5 books
Moonlight Magic
by Stacy Reid
2022
Jenny Kincaid never meant to fall for an English earl passing through Colorado, but Caleb Callahan is unlike any man she has known. As his duty calls him back across the ocean, stolen nights and whispered promises force them to weigh passion against the heavy pull of obligation.
Lady Sara and the Outlaw
by Stacy Reid
2022
Set in the world of the Kincaids, this story pairs titled Lady Sara with a man branded an outlaw. When refined upbringing collides with the brutal realities of the frontier, both must decide how much they will risk for freedom, justice, and the chance to build a life together.
Lawless
by Stacy Reid
2019
Known across the territory as “Lawless,” Noah Kincaid avoids attachments and complications. During a train robbery he realizes outlaws are targeting fellow passenger Ada Bancroft, not the money. Rescuing her launches a perilous journey through the wilds of Wyoming and a scorching, unexpected love neither can afford to lose.
Tempting Bethany
by Stacy Reid
2018
After a brutal marriage to a saloon owner, Bethany Galloway flees to her brother’s ranch, always fearing her past will catch up. When gunslinger Joshua Kincaid, the man who once won her in a card game, comes to help, danger forces them together and long denied desire finally erupts.
Taming Elijah
by Stacy Reid
2017
English lady Sheridan Wentworth sought safety in the wild American West, only to find fresh dangers and unwanted suitors. She turns to taciturn rancher Elijah Kincaid for protection, determined to prove she is more than a fragile society miss and the one woman he cannot walk away from.
Series background & context
The Kincaids series trades London’s drawing rooms for the raw beauty and danger of the American West. Centered on the Kincaid family, these historical romances follow siblings and loved ones as they build lives, ranches, and relationships on the frontier.
Taming Elijah introduces the tone and stakes. Three years after leaving the safety of London society, Sheridan Wentworth now lives in a land where bandits, rough men, and vast distances are part of daily life. Harassed by suitors who covet her wealth more than her heart, she turns to Elijah Kincaid for protection. Elijah is as untamed as the country around him and sees Sheridan as fragile and out of place, but she is determined to prove she is his equal in grit and in love.
In Tempting Bethany, Bethany Galloway has already tasted how cruel the West can be. A disastrous marriage to a saloon owner leaves her abused, nearly sold, and desperate to escape. Years later, when she reaches safety near the Kincaid ranch, she crosses paths again with Joshua Kincaid, the man who once “won” an hour with her in a card game and then walked away. He becomes both her protector and the man whose kisses make her question whether leaving the West is really what she wants.
Lawless: Noah Kincaid follows the most dangerous of the brothers. Noah is known across the territory as “Lawless,” a gunman and tracker with a ruthless reputation. On a train journey he notices that a gang’s real target is not cash but fellow passenger Ada Bancroft. Noah rescues her, and the two are forced to travel together through the wilds of Wyoming while armed men hunt them. As he and his loyal dog Dutch fight to keep Ada safe, their wary partnership deepens into something tender and fiercely passionate.
In Moonlight Magic: Jenny Kincaid, the focus shifts to the Kincaids’ sister. Jenny never expected to fall for an English nobleman, but Caleb Callahan, newly made Earl of Tallant, upends her assumptions. Their stolen moments glow with attraction, even as the looming reality of his duties in England threatens to pull them apart. The story moves from Colorado Territory to Victorian ballrooms, highlighting the clash between frontier freedom and the strictures of aristocratic life.
A forthcoming installment, Lady Sara and the Outlaw, promises to bring a titled lady into this rugged world, pairing her with a man whose livelihood and choices place him on the wrong side of the law. It continues the series’ interest in how class, culture, and geography complicate love.
Across all the books, The Kincaids balances shootouts and cattle drives with found family, healing from trauma, and the quiet domestic moments that make happily ever afters believable. The stories are gritty in places, but they never lose sight of hope.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.



















Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts