Sally Gunning Books in Order
Browse Sally Gunning books in order, with quick summaries, series guides, and easy where to start tips for her Cape Cod mysteries and historical fiction.
Last updated: July 9, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Publication Order
16 books
Hot Water
by Sally Gunning
1990
Pete arrives to catalog Edna Hitchcock's books and finds her dead in a bathtub that is still warm. With suspicion circling Edna's daughter and Connie back on the island, Pete gets pulled into a messy first case.
Under Water
by Sally Gunning
1992
Peter finds a pregnant teenager's body drifting in the Sound, with only a class ring to point the way. He and Connie follow the trail into island secrets and end up trapped in a tidal cave with a killer close by.
Ice Water
by Sally Gunning
1993
Christmas on Nashtoba turns ugly when a popular businessman is shot at a holiday party. Pete hunts for a killer tied to old grudges and development battles, while worrying that Connie may be next.
Troubled Water
by Sally Gunning
1993
The double death of two beloved spinster sisters shakes quiet Nashtoba. Pete digs into the case and finds that even the island's gentlest corners can hide resentment, secrets, and murder.
Rough Water
by Sally Gunning
1994
A whale-watching trip should be a break for Pete, Connie, Polly, and Polly's fiance. Instead, the outing turns gruesome when a man is found impaled on a harpoon, sending Pete into another tight-knit island investigation.
Still Water
by Sally Gunning
1995
Pete agrees to go undercover as a handyman after a worried husband fears someone wants to kill his young wife. Then murder strikes, and Pete has to sort out which smiling face in the household hides the real threat.
Deep Water
by Sally Gunning
1996
When Nashtoba's resident drunk suddenly flashes a pile of cash and turns up dead the next morning, Pete and his sister Polly start digging. What looks like a strange island tragedy quickly turns into a mess of money, motive, and danger.
Muddy Water
by Sally Gunning
1997
Peter Bartholomew starts asking questions when a friend's bride never makes it to the altar. Her murder uncovers jealousy, tangled loyalties, and connections that land far too close to home.
Dirty Water
by Sally Gunning
1998
Pete and Connie's honeymoon ends fast when an elderly friend confesses to shooting a local accountant. With a hurricane bearing down on Nashtoba, buried secrets and old sins start rising as quickly as the storm.
Fire Water
by Sally Gunning
1999
When a little girl finds a human skull in Pete Bartholomew's marsh, the remains turn out to belong to an old flame who vanished years earlier. A second skull and a flood of local gossip leave Pete and Connie scrambling to clear their names.
The Widow's War
by Sally Gunning
2006
When her whaling husband is lost at sea in 1761, Lyddie Berry loses more than companionship. Faced with laws that hand her property and future to a male guardian, she fights for independence in a Cape Cod village that wants her compliant.
Bound
by Sally Gunning
2008
After her father binds her into servitude in colonial New England, Alice Cole grows up with little control over her fate. When danger closes in, she runs to Boston and Satucket, where freedom comes with hard choices.
The Rebellion of Jane Clarke
by Sally Gunning
2010
In Satucket, Jane Clarke is caught in an old family feud after an act of cruelty turns suspicion toward her father. Sent to Boston on the eve of the Boston Massacre, she must question loyalty, truth, and the stories her community tells itself.
Benjamin Franklin's Bastard
by Sally Gunning
2013
This novel imagines the tangled lives around Benjamin Franklin's illegitimate son, William. As father and son are pulled to opposite sides of the Revolution, Anne and Deborah struggle with love, loyalty, and the cost of Franklin's choices.
Monticello
by Sally Gunning
2016
Returning from France to Virginia, Martha Jefferson Randolph finds her father's world shaped by politics, debt, and slavery. As Thomas Jefferson pulls away, she struggles to protect her family, her conscience, and the home she loves.
Painting the Light
by Sally Gunning
2021
On Martha's Vineyard in 1898, Ida Pease is forced to sort through the wreckage of her life after a storm takes her unreliable husband. As old ambitions stir, she must separate truth from lies and decide what future she wants.
Where should I start?
If you want her Cape Cod historical trilogy: The Widow's War → Bound → The Rebellion of Jane Clarke
If you want a standalone about famous American families: Benjamin Franklin's Bastard → Monticello
If you want a later New England novel about art and reinvention: Painting the Light
If you want her mystery side first: Hot Water → Under Water → Ice Water
Author bio
Sally Gunning was born in Quincy, Massachusetts, in 1951, and she has spent her life in New England. Her family roots in Brewster on Cape Cod go back centuries, which helps explain why so much of her fiction feels tied to place, weather, work, and the long memory of local history.
She came to writing early, mostly because she loved reading so much that one rainy day she ran out of books.
As a girl she moved from Dr. Seuss to The Catcher in the Rye, and the urge to tell stories stuck. The writing career itself came later. After graduating from the University of Rhode Island, she worked a string of jobs, including museum tour guide, cruise ship stewardess, bank accountant, and office manager for a country doctor.
That doctor's decision to take one extra day off each week changed things. Gunning turned the day into writing time, shut herself in with a typewriter, and taught herself how to build a novel. What she expected to be practice work became the start of a long run in print.
Her first decade as a novelist was spent in mystery. The Peter Bartholomew books, beginning with Hot Water, follow an odd-job entrepreneur on a fictional Cape flavored island called Nashtoba, where ordinary errands keep turning into murder cases. Pete's uneasy connection to his ex-wife Connie gives the series a steady human thread, and the books already show what Gunning does well: close communities, buried grudges, and people whose pasts do not stay buried for long.
Then she turned toward the deeper past under her own feet.
Living in Brewster, walking old roads, and digging into local and family history pulled her toward historical fiction. That shift produced the Satucket novels, The Widow's War, Bound, and The Rebellion of Jane Clarke, books set on Cape Cod in the years before the American Revolution. Gunning often centers women who are boxed in by law, custom, or family, then shows how they push back, sometimes quietly, sometimes at real personal cost.
She later widened her scope while keeping that same interest in overlooked corners of American history. Benjamin Franklin's Bastard imagines the family drama around Benjamin Franklin and his son William. Monticello looks at Martha Jefferson Randolph and the world around Thomas Jefferson. Painting the Light, set on Martha's Vineyard in 1898, follows a woman trying to rebuild her life after loss and disappointment. Readers who like family tension, moral gray areas, and a strong sense of time and place usually find a lot to hold onto in those books.
Across her work, the same concerns keep returning: New England landscapes, the texture of daily labor, the limits placed on women, and the uneasy gap between public history and private life. She has also served the history of her town directly, creating local history tours, serving as president of the Brewster Historical Society, and becoming a fellow of the Massachusetts Historical Society. Her essays and commentary have appeared in major newspapers and literary outlets as well.
She still lives in Brewster with her husband. It seems like the right place for a writer who keeps asking what happened here before we arrived, and what those old stories still have to say.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.
































Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts