Otter Lake Mystery Books in Order

A dead man emerges from Otter Lake’s Tunnel of Love with Erica Bloom’s aunt as the sole witness. Determined to clear her, Erica and Freddie Ng investigate local secrets despite the sheriff’s objections to their interference.

Erica Bloom returns home to help her mother’s struggling retreat and discovers a murder mystery. When people connected to a humiliating teenage prank begin dying, suspicion falls on Erica, forcing her to uncover the real killer.

At a Gatsby-themed New Year’s party, Sheriff Grady Forrester’s date nearly dies from a poisoned cocktail. Erica Bloom must clear her former boyfriend before midnight while confronting lingering feelings and the possibility of another attack.

Erica Bloom’s romantic getaway becomes a murder investigation when a storm traps a reality television family at her mother’s lodge. After the patriarch dies during a power failure, Erica searches for a killer among the stranded guests.

A missing maid of honor turns up dead just before an Otter Lake wedding. With Grady away and a strict replacement sheriff in charge, Erica Bloom and her security team investigate the events surrounding the celebration.

Teenagers discover human bones near an orchard associated with an old witch legend. Erica Bloom’s security team investigates a long-vanished local’s connection to the property as revived ghost stories obscure the truth behind the death.