Otherworld (Skylar Dorset) Books in Order

The Otherworld books are a compact YA fantasy series set in and around Boston, where old houses, subway tunnels, and ordinary city corners can hide supernatural trouble. The heart of the story is Selkie Stewart, a teenage girl who has been raised by two eccentric great-aunts and told almost nothing about her real past.

Then the lie around her life starts to crack.

Once Selkie learns she is tied to the faerie world, the series opens into hidden courts, dangerous bargains, and a prophecy that says she could bring down the Seelie Court. That sounds huge, but the books keep it personal. Selkie is trying to understand where she comes from, whether she can trust the people protecting her, and what love looks like when secrets are built into nearly everything.

Boston matters here.

Dorset uses the city as more than a backdrop. Beacon Hill streets, brownstones, and the T all feed the mood, so the magic feels close to everyday life instead of tucked away in a distant kingdom. Even when the story moves deeper into the Otherworld, that grounded city feeling stays in place. It gives the books a fun mix of urban fantasy, fairy tale weirdness, and teen coming-of-age drama.

Ben, also known as Benedict Le Fay, is central to the ongoing tension. He is part protector, part love interest, and part mystery, which lets the series play with romance without losing sight of danger. Selkie's aunts add humor and warmth, and the wider cast keeps the world feeling crowded in a good way, full of people who know more than they first admit.

The companion novellas widen the picture. The Girl Who Kissed a Lie works as a prequel, showing Selkie trying to have a normal summer before the bigger truths break loose. The Girl Who Read the Stars steps sideways to follow Merrow, a Fay of the Summer Equinox, and adds another angle on prophecy, fate, and how young people in this world grow into powers they do not fully understand.

Prophecy is everywhere, but the books do not forget smaller emotions. Selkie wants answers, safety, and some control over a story other people keep writing about her. That tension gives the series its pull.

Overall, expect a quick-moving story with romance, humor, looming destiny, and family secrets at its center. The stakes grow from personal confusion to full supernatural crisis, but the books stay easiest to love when they focus on Selkie's voice, her found family, and the strange idea that the world might make a little more sense if goblins are to blame for the bad commute.