Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

Magical Mystery Book Club Books in Order

Part ofElizabeth Pantley Books in Order

Browse the Magical Mystery Book Club books in order by Elizabeth Pantley, with summaries, series background, reading order, and a clear place to start.

Last updated: July 15, 2026

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Magical Mystery Book Club books in publication order

Sort:

11 books

1

Cowboys and Chaos

by Elizabeth Pantley

2022

A new enchanted mystery drops the book club into an Old West town in the Arizona desert. Among saloons, horses, and cowboys, Paige and her friends face two puzzles that stand between them and home.

2

Shifting and Shenanigans

by Elizabeth Pantley

2022

Paige and Aunt Glo inherit an inn with a hidden library of enchanted mysteries. When their new book club is pulled into a murder case, they must solve it together or remain trapped inside the story.

3

Vampires and Villains

by Elizabeth Pantley

2022

The magical book club lands aboard a Hawaii-bound cruise ship, where their charming new companion becomes the prime suspect after a murder. To leave the book, they must decide whether he needs help or is hiding the truth.

4

Bakeries and Buffoonery

by Elizabeth Pantley

2023

The enchanted book club enters a mystery set during Frosting's annual cake competition, where festival murders have become an alarming tradition. Between suspicious citizens, odd backpacks, and mountains of cake, they must stop the next killing.

5

Genies and Gibberish

by Elizabeth Pantley

2023

The enchanted book club arrives at an Arizona mountain mansion and discovers an antique lamp with a startling secret. After their host falls from a mysterious doorway, the group must uncover whether magic or murder is responsible.

6

Secrets and Scallywags

by Elizabeth Pantley

2023

A mysterious pirate boat washes ashore near an island community, along with rumors of lost treasure. When the book club meets the ghosts tied to the wreck, finding the treasure becomes their only route home.

7

Meditation and Mischief

by Elizabeth Pantley

2024

A wellness retreat promises yoga, meditation, and ocean views, but the magical book club finds a dead body instead. At an acting-school reunion, old grudges make every guest a possible killer.

8

Sprites and Scuttlebutt

by Elizabeth Pantley

2024

The book club enters the sprite Kingdom of Everglow just as a royal staff member dies and a princess falls into a deathlike sleep. They must expose the attack on the royal family and find a cure.

9

Carousels and Characters

by Elizabeth Pantley

2025

The book club is pulled into an enchanted amusement park where thefts have escalated from missing props to a threat against the whole business. They must identify the thief before the park descends into chaos.

10

Puzzles and Premieres

by Elizabeth Pantley

2025

A magical journey takes the book club to a snowy film festival packed with celebrities and premieres. When a famous actress disappears, the group follows clues hidden in enchanted jigsaw puzzles to solve the case.

11
New

Critters and Crimes

by Elizabeth Pantley

2026

Inside a cozy mystery set in a riverside town, the book club joins another local reading group before a body appears. The most useful clues come from an unexpected source: the critters living in the house.

Magical Mystery Book Club books in chronological order

  1. Book cover for "Shifting and Shenanigans"

    Shifting and Shenanigans

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2022Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 1
  2. Book cover for "Vampires and Villains"

    Vampires and Villains

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2022Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 2
  3. Book cover for "Cowboys and Chaos"

    Cowboys and Chaos

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2022Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 3
  4. Book cover for "Bakeries and Buffoonery"

    Bakeries and Buffoonery

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2023Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 4
  5. Book cover for "Genies and Gibberish"

    Genies and Gibberish

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2023Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 5
  6. Book cover for "Secrets and Scallywags"

    Secrets and Scallywags

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2023Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 6
  7. Book cover for "Sprites and Scuttlebutt"

    Sprites and Scuttlebutt

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2024Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 7
  8. Book cover for "Meditation and Mischief"

    Meditation and Mischief

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2024Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 8
  9. Book cover for "Carousels and Characters"

    Carousels and Characters

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2025Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 9
  10. Book cover for "Puzzles and Premieres"

    Puzzles and Premieres

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2025Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 10
  11. Book cover for "Critters and Crimes"

    Critters and Crimes

    by Elizabeth Pantley

    2026Magical Mystery Book Club, Book 11

Series background & context

The Magical Mystery Book Club series begins when Paige and her adventurous Aunt Glo inherit an old country inn from their great-grandmother, GeeGee. The inheritance comes with a surprise hidden in the basement: a secret library filled with cozy mysteries. These are not ordinary books. They are enchanted.

Paige, Glo, and a growing group of friends form a book club around the collection. When they choose a title and begin to read, the mystery springs to life around them. The members are pulled into the story as characters, with a crime to solve and no easy way back home.

They have to reach the end of the book.

That rule gives every installment a built-in clock. The club can enjoy the strange new world they have landed in, but first they must work out what happened, identify the culprit, and survive the trouble that comes with being part of the plot. Their regular companions include Zell, an outspoken older club member, and Frank, a cat with plenty to say.

Each adventure changes the scenery and the kind of magic at play. Shifting and Shenanigans introduces the hidden library and its dangerous first journey. Later books visit a Hawaiian cruise, an Old West town, a cake-obsessed festival, a pirate-haunted island, a sprite kingdom, a wellness retreat, an enchanted theme park, and a snowy film festival. The club might meet ghosts, shifters, genies, vampires, or other paranormal locals, but the central task remains a cozy whodunit.

The tone is playful, warm, and lightly spooky rather than grim. There are bodies, suspects, secrets, and occasional real danger, but there is also cake, travel, jokes, friendship, and the pleasure of seeing a familiar group adapt to another impossible situation. The premise is deliberately flexible, so every book can offer a different setting without losing the series' core cast.

Most individual mysteries have their own resolution, making the books approachable as standalones. Still, starting with Shifting and Shenanigans makes the magical library, the club's friendships, and the rules of their journeys easier to follow. Read in order for the fullest experience, especially if the idea of a book club that literally enters its reading list sounds like your kind of escape.

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

Comments

Did we miss something? Have feedback?

Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts

We only use your email to notify you about replies.

All comments are moderated.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.