Forbidden Wishes Books in Order
Part ofWhitney G Books in OrderSee the Forbidden Wishes books in order by Whitney G, with summaries, series background, and reading-order help for these taboo, high-angst romances.
Last updated: July 3, 2026
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).
Forbidden Wishes books in publication order
3 books
I Wish I Would've Told You
by Whitney G
2023
A high school star and the goth girl in the bleachers build a secret, intense connection that should never have happened. The biggest problem is not how hard they fell, it is who he was already dating.
I Wish I Would’ve Chosen You
by Whitney G
2024
This forbidden romance leans hard into the choice no one should make. Attraction, bad timing, and an off-limits connection turn into the kind of emotional mess that refuses to stay buried.
I Wish I Would’ve Warned You
by Whitney G
2025
A dangerous dare and an instant attraction would already be trouble. The situation gets much worse when the man she cannot stop wanting is about to become family.
Forbidden Wishes books in chronological order
Series background & context
The Forbidden Wishes books are Whitney G. leaning straight into bad ideas, the kind that are clearly going to hurt, clearly going to get messy, and clearly impossible for the characters to resist anyway.
This is a more taboo, high-angst branch of her catalog. The books are connected by mood and theme more than by one shared cast, and the series is upfront about what it is doing. These stories are built around lines that should not be crossed, sibling complications, teacher-student tension, and family ties that make desire feel even more dangerous.
The first book throws a star quarterback into a secret, toxic connection with the wrong sister. That is the kind of premise that tells you exactly what series you are in. Emotions run hot, but so do bad decisions. The point is not that these people behave perfectly. The point is that they do not, and then they have to live with the fallout.
Later books keep pushing that idea. One romance circles a professor and a woman he should never want. Another uses an impending step-sibling connection to make every spark feel like a mistake in progress. Whitney G. does not sand those edges down. She lets the discomfort be part of the story.
Even with the darker setup, these books are still romance-forward. The characters are not only chasing temptation. They are also trying to understand why the connection feels impossible to walk away from. That gives the series more emotional pull than a simple shock-value premise would.
If you want taboo contemporary romance with a lot of tension, a little danger, and characters who know they are inviting trouble, Forbidden Wishes is exactly that kind of read.
Edited by
Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.
Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.



















Comments
Did we miss something? Have feedback?
Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts