Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

Candy-Coated Mysteries Books in Order

Part ofNancy Coco Books in Order

Find the Candy-Coated Mysteries by Nancy Coco in order, with short summaries, reading order help, series background, and where to begin.

Last updated: June 10, 2026

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Publication Order

Sort:

18 books

1

All Fudged Up

by Nancy Coco

2013

Allie McMurphy returns to Mackinac Island to restore her family hotel and fudge shop, then finds a body hidden on the property. With suspicion falling on her family, she has to untangle old grudges before the business is ruined.

2

To Fudge or Not to Fudge

by Nancy Coco

2014

During Lilac Festival, Allie's dog digs up human remains, and her stint on a cooking show leads into a fresh trail of danger. To protect her sweet new life on Mackinac Island, she has to outthink a killer.

3

All I Want for Christmas is Fudge

by Nancy Coco

2015

Jenn Christensen comes back to snowy Mackinac Island for the Santa Fun Run, hoping to reconnect with Shane, and instead finds a dead Santa in the snow. With suspicion falling on her, Jenn and Allie hunt for the killer before Christmas is spoiled.

4

Oh Say Can You Fudge

by Nancy Coco

2015

Preparing for the Fourth of July, Allie hires a star pyrotechnician for Mackinac Island's fireworks, only to find him murdered before the warehouse explodes. With the holiday and her reputation on the line, she starts chasing answers.

5

All You Need is Fudge

by Nancy Coco

2016

As Allie creates chocolate centerpieces for the annual yacht race, she and Mal pull a body from the marina. When someone close to Rex becomes a suspect, Allie digs into feuds and buried secrets around the island.

6

Deck the Halls with Fudge

by Nancy Coco

2017

Newlywed seniors Frances and Douglas Devaney spot a horse-drawn sleigh carrying a corpse through the snow. What should be a postcard-perfect Mackinac Christmas quickly turns into a chilly little murder puzzle.

7

Oh, Fudge!

by Nancy Coco

2017

Allie's estranged cousin Tori returns to Mackinac Island just in time to be found beside a corpse in the butterfly house. Family tension and old resentments collide as Allie tries to clear her cousin's name.

8

Forever Fudge

by Nancy Coco

2018

Over Labor Day weekend, a TV crew descends on Mackinac Island, and Allie's dog finds a real murder behind the hotel. A taunting note makes the case personal and pushes Allie into a dangerous game with the killer.

9

Fudge Bites

by Nancy Coco

2019

During Mackinac Island's annual zombie walk, Allie's cat leads her to a body in the alley behind the hotel and fudge shop. To expose the killer, Allie and Rex have to look past costumes, tricks, and local secrets.

10

Have Yourself a Fudgy Little Christmas

by Nancy Coco

2020

While waiting for renovations to end, Allie spends Christmas baking fudge and staying with a friend, then answers a mysterious note and finds a woman dead in a snowdrift. Holiday cheer quickly gives way to another icy investigation.

11

Here Comes the Fudge

by Nancy Coco

2021

As Jenn's wedding approaches, Allie and Jenn find Shane standing over a body with a bloody knife. To keep the ceremony from turning into a jailhouse disaster, Allie has to clear the groom.

12

A Midsummer Night's Fudge

by Nancy Coco

2022

After the queen of Mackinac Island's midsummer celebration turns up dead in the lake, Allie is pulled into the case while juggling festival duties and fudge making. Rumors, pranks, and threats make the summer event anything but charming.

13

Give Fudge a Chance

by Nancy Coco

2023

At the Mackinac County Fair, Allie is focused on the fudge competition until she finds a body inside the haunted house. When a second suspicious death hits close to home, she realizes the fairground mystery is bigger than it first looked.

14

Having a Fudgy Christmas Time

by Nancy Coco

2023

Carol Tunisian is busy with the senior center Christmas Ball when she finds a dead man inside the building. Breaking her promise to stay out of it, she teams up with her silver-haired friends and leans on Allie to solve the case.

15

Fudgy Christmas Murders

by Nancy Coco

2024

This collection gathers the Mackinac Island holiday novellas, following Allie and her friends through snowy murders, Christmas parties, and seasonal trouble. It is a handy way to read the festive side of the series in one volume.

16

Three Fudges and a Baby

by Nancy Coco

2024

Jenn is overdue, the island's busy season is starting, and Allie's hands are full before a doula is found holding a gun over her fiance's body. With time running short before the baby arrives, Allie races to prove the woman innocent.

17

Fudge and Marriage

by Nancy Coco

2025

Two weeks before her wedding to Rex, Allie is already dealing with family chaos when she finds a woman dead and another woman weeping nearby. She wants a quiet June ceremony, but first she has to solve one more dangerous case.

18
New

Some Like It Fudgy

by Nancy Coco

2026

Newly married Allie brings fudge to Rex's ex-wife as a peace offering and instead finds her dead in the studio mid-photo shoot. With gossip swirling and several people fleeing the scene, she has to sort out old grudges and hidden secrets.

Series background & context

The Candy-Coated Mysteries are built around Allie McMurphy and the Historic McMurphy Hotel and Fudge Shop on Mackinac Island. Allie comes back to the island to keep the family business going, and in All Fudged Up that plan goes sideways the moment murder enters the picture. The series never forgets that the hotel and fudge counter are not just scenery. They are the reason Allie stays, works, and keeps getting dragged into island trouble.

Mackinac Island gives these books their personality. It is a tourist destination, a small community, and a place with long memories, all at once. During the high season, visitors pour in and everything feels bright and crowded. In the colder months, the island gets quieter, and that change in pace lets the books show a different side of local life.

Nothing stays secret for long there.

That is great for a cozy mystery. Allie is surrounded by people who know family history, carry grudges, protect traditions, or have strong opinions about who belongs. Her circle grows over the series, especially through her friendship with Jenn Carpenter, her dealings with Carol Tunisian, and her relationship with police officer Rex Manning. The mysteries hit harder because they usually land in the middle of people Allie actually sees and depends on every day.

The books also use seasonal events well. Fireworks, yacht races, fairs, parades, weddings, Halloween fun, and Christmas snow all become part of the setup. A title like A Midsummer Night's Fudge feels very different from Have Yourself a Fudgy Little Christmas, even though both are recognizably part of the same world.

The mood stays light without feeling flimsy. There are recipes, pets, small-town humor, and a steady undercurrent of romance, but Allie is also dealing with a real workload. She has rooms to fill, repairs to manage, fudge to make, and a family legacy to protect. That practical side helps keep the series grounded.

It is cozy, but it is not weightless.

If you want a long-running culinary mystery series where the town, the business, and the relationships all matter, this is what to expect. Start at the beginning and you get the full arc: Allie learning the island all over again, building her place in it, and solving one very sticky murder after another.

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

Comments

Did we miss something? Have feedback?

Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts

We only use your email to notify you about replies.

All comments are moderated.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.

All 18 Candy-Coated Mysteries Books in Order (2026)