Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

Bay Tanner Books in Order

Part ofKathryn R Wall Books in Order

See the Bay Tanner books in order by Kathryn R. Wall, with short summaries, series background, and tips on where to start this Lowcountry mystery series.

Last updated: July 1, 2026

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Bay Tanner books in publication order

Sort:

14 books

1

In for a Penny

by Kathryn R Wall

2000

After surviving her husband's murder, Bay retreats to Hilton Head only to be drawn into a shaky development scheme threatening her old friends. A body near a ruined plantation links money, land, and grief in unsettling ways.

2

And Not a Penny More

by Kathryn R Wall

2002

Bay's old friend Jordan returns to South Carolina convinced her mother did not die of natural causes. Between family pressure, international intrigue, and a hurricane bearing down, Bay is pulled into a volatile search for the truth.

3

Perdition House

by Kathryn R Wall

2003

A distant cousin's call from jail pulls Bay into a family tangle of missing women, old plantations, and dangerous pursuers. The search for answers sends her through Civil War shadows and toward a deadly reckoning.

4

Judas Island

by Kathryn R Wall

2004

Back from Paris and nursing fresh heartbreak, Bay is drawn into trouble at her father's Beaufort home and the death of an archaeologist. An old grave on a coastal island leads to a buried conspiracy with deep local roots.

5

Resurrection Road

by Kathryn R Wall

2005

A bitter teenager accuses Bay of knowing the truth about his father's death, then vanishes, leaving blood behind. Soon Bay and her lover are suspects, forced to untangle corruption, grief, and buried history.

6

Bishop's Reach

by Kathryn R Wall

2006

A terrified call girl, a long-missing heir, and a beaten corpse on the beach throw Bay into several cases at once. What looks like separate trouble slowly tightens into one dangerous puzzle.

7

Sanctuary Hill

by Kathryn R Wall

2007

After a summer storm, Bay finds a gruesome clue drifting in on the tide and stumbles into a world of old beliefs and newer crimes. A missing wife, a backwoods commune, and rising danger pull her deeper in.

8

The Mercy Oak

by Kathryn R Wall

2008

A suspected hit-and-run draws Bay into a tangle of robberies, prejudice, and Lowcountry secrets. When people close to her start disappearing and someone wants her off the case, the investigation becomes painfully personal.

9

Covenant Hall

by Kathryn R Wall

2009

Bay takes a case involving a desperate mother searching for relatives who could save her leukemia-stricken daughter. At the same time, her father's whispered confession opens a family mystery that cuts much closer to home.

10

Canaan's Gate

by Kathryn R Wall

2010

A timid bank employee asks Bay to look into a scheme aimed at a wealthy elderly couple, then disappears after a sudden death. As Bay's new marriage strains, every lead points to divided loyalties and carefully hidden motives.

11

Jericho Cay

by Kathryn R Wall

2011

A secretive true-crime writer hires Bay to revisit the disappearance of a millionaire who vanished from his private island. Strange behavior, an old supposed suicide, and mounting lies make the cold case feel dangerously alive.

12

St. John's Folly

by Kathryn R Wall

2013

Bay Tanner starts receiving childish, unsettling messages from a stalker just as a new case lands on her desk. An aging landowner, a greedy nephew, and a suspicious death turn memory and real estate into dangerous ground.

13

Like a Bad Penny

by Kathryn R Wall

2014

When a man from novelist Elizabeth Stanton's past resurfaces and approaches her young daughter, panic sends her running again. Bay Tanner helps Liz plot a way out before an old nightmare turns deadly.

14

Jordan Point

by Kathryn R Wall

2015

An old school friend asks Bay Tanner to help an abused woman before things turn fatal. Then the husband vanishes from his yacht, and Bay must decide whether the battered wife is a victim, a suspect, or both.

Bay Tanner books in chronological order

  1. Book cover for "In for a Penny"

    In for a Penny

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2000Bay Tanner, Book 1
  2. Book cover for "And Not a Penny More"

    And Not a Penny More

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2002Bay Tanner, Book 2
  3. Book cover for "Perdition House"

    Perdition House

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2003Bay Tanner, Book 3
  4. Book cover for "Judas Island"

    Judas Island

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2004Bay Tanner, Book 4
  5. Book cover for "Resurrection Road"

    Resurrection Road

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2005Bay Tanner, Book 5
  6. Book cover for "Bishop's Reach"

    Bishop's Reach

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2006Bay Tanner, Book 6
  7. Book cover for "Sanctuary Hill"

    Sanctuary Hill

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2007Bay Tanner, Book 7
  8. Book cover for "The Mercy Oak"

    The Mercy Oak

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2008Bay Tanner, Book 8
  9. Book cover for "Covenant Hall"

    Covenant Hall

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2009Bay Tanner, Book 9
  10. Book cover for "Canaan's Gate"

    Canaan's Gate

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2010Bay Tanner, Book 10
  11. Book cover for "Jericho Cay"

    Jericho Cay

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2011Bay Tanner, Book 11
  12. Book cover for "St. John's Folly"

    St. John's Folly

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2013Bay Tanner, Book 12
  13. Book cover for "Like a Bad Penny"

    Like a Bad Penny

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2014Bay Tanner, Book 13
  14. Book cover for "Jordan Point"

    Jordan Point

    by Kathryn R Wall

    2015Bay Tanner, Book 14

Series background & context

The Bay Tanner books follow Lydia Baynard "Bay" Tanner, a Hilton Head woman who starts out as a financial consultant and becomes, almost despite herself, an investigator. In In for a Penny, Bay is already carrying a lot. She is newly widowed, badly shaken, and trying to retreat from the world when money troubles, local loyalties, and a suspicious death pull her back in. That mix, personal grief and professional curiosity, sets the tone for the whole series.

The setting is a huge part of the appeal. These books live in Hilton Head Island, Beaufort, and the surrounding South Carolina Lowcountry, with its marshes, private islands, old family homes, resort polish, and long, uneasy history. Wall uses the place well. The landscape is pretty, but it is never just pretty. Land deals, class tension, buried family stories, and old community wounds keep surfacing right alongside the bodies.

Bay does not work alone for long. Her world includes her father, retired Judge Talbot Simpson, the sharp young Erik Whiteside, and Red Tanner, her late husband's brother, who starts out as a law-enforcement ally and becomes even more central to her life. Around them are caretakers, old friends, clients, and island insiders who make the series feel connected from book to book. Cases may begin with a missing person, a suspicious death, or a shaky business arrangement, but they usually end up brushing against Bay's own circle.

She is not a superhero.

That is one reason the series works. Bay is capable, but she doubts herself, grieves, makes mistakes, and keeps going anyway. The books sit in a nice middle ground between private-eye fiction and Southern traditional mystery. There is danger and there is romance, but there is also a lot of attention to trust, family obligation, and the question of how much the past should be allowed to rule the present.

As the series goes on, the emotional threads deepen. Judas Island and Resurrection Road lean into buried crimes and personal fallout. Sanctuary Hill and The Mercy Oak bring in local belief, prejudice, and the cost of protecting the people Bay loves. Covenant Hall and Canaan's Gate are full of family secrets and moral gray areas. By the time you reach Jericho Cay, St. John's Folly, and Jordan Point, Bay is older, more experienced, and still surrounded by cases that refuse to stay tidy.

These books are best read in order if you can manage it. The mysteries usually stand on their own, but Bay's relationships, losses, and changes carry forward in a satisfying way. If you want a series with a strong sense of place, a steady central character, and mysteries tied to family and community, Bay Tanner is an easy one to settle into.

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

Comments

Did we miss something? Have feedback?

Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts

We only use your email to notify you about replies.

All comments are moderated.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.